Fundamentals

Many small business owners still equate automation with sprawling factory floors and robotic arms, a vision seemingly distant from their daily realities of juggling invoices and customer emails. This perception, while understandable, overlooks a fundamental shift ● automation’s cultural impact is now measurable within the very fabric of small to medium-sized businesses, not just in sprawling industrial complexes. We can discern this shift through metrics that move beyond mere efficiency gains, metrics that tap into the evolving mindset and operational DNA of these enterprises.

Efficiency Gains Initial View

At first glance, efficiency metrics appear to be the obvious indicators of automation’s impact. Consider metrics like Processing Time Per Task. If a previously manual invoice processing system took an employee 30 minutes per invoice, and an automated system reduces this to five minutes, that’s a clear efficiency gain. Similarly, a decrease in Error Rates in data entry after automation points towards operational improvement.

These are tangible benefits, and they certainly reflect a business becoming more streamlined. However, focusing solely on these metrics provides an incomplete picture. They tell us about operational improvements, but not necessarily about a deeper cultural shift towards automation.

Beyond Simple Efficiency

To truly gauge a cultural shift, we must look beyond these surface-level efficiency gains. The question becomes ● is automation merely a tool being used, or is it becoming integrated into the very way the business thinks and operates? A business can implement automated tools without fundamentally changing its culture. For instance, a company might adopt a CRM system to automate customer follow-ups, yet still maintain a reactive, rather than proactive, customer service Meaning ● Customer service, within the context of SMB growth, involves providing assistance and support to customers before, during, and after a purchase, a vital function for business survival. approach.

The tool is there, but the mindset hasn’t shifted. Therefore, we need metrics that reveal a more profound integration of automation into the business culture.

Employee Time Allocation A Key Metric

One revealing metric is the shift in Employee Time Allocation. Automation, at its core, is about freeing up human capital from repetitive, mundane tasks. If, after implementing automation, you observe employees spending less time on routine data entry and more time on strategic planning, customer relationship building, or product development, this signals a cultural shift. It indicates that the business is not just becoming more efficient at existing tasks, but is also evolving in how it utilizes its human resources.

This is a crucial distinction. Are employees simply doing the same job faster, or are they engaging in higher-value activities?

Customer Satisfaction and Automation

Another vital area to examine is Customer Satisfaction. Automation, when implemented thoughtfully, should enhance the customer experience. Metrics like Customer Support Ticket Resolution Time and Customer Feedback Scores can offer insights.

If automation leads to faster response times, more personalized interactions (through AI-powered chatbots, for example), and ultimately happier customers, it suggests a culture that understands automation as a means to improve customer relationships, not just cut costs. Conversely, if automation is implemented poorly, leading to impersonal interactions or frustrating automated systems, customer satisfaction Meaning ● Customer Satisfaction: Ensuring customer delight by consistently meeting and exceeding expectations, fostering loyalty and advocacy. might decline, indicating a cultural mismatch or a flawed implementation strategy.

Metrics of Innovation and Adaptation

A more subtle, yet profoundly important, indicator of cultural shift is the business’s Rate of Innovation and Adaptation. Automation can empower businesses to experiment more readily. With routine tasks handled by machines, employees have the bandwidth to explore new ideas, test different approaches, and adapt to changing market conditions more quickly.

Metrics like the Number of New Initiatives Launched Per Quarter or the Speed of Response to Market Changes can reflect this increased agility. A business that embraces automation culturally is likely to become more innovative and adaptable, not just more efficient at doing the same old things.

Training and Skill Development

Finally, consider metrics related to Training and Skill Development. A business undergoing a true automation cultural shift Meaning ● Embracing technology and adapting company culture for efficiency and growth in small to medium businesses. will invest in upskilling its workforce. As automation takes over routine tasks, new roles and responsibilities emerge, often requiring different skill sets.

Metrics such as Employee Participation in Training Programs focused on new technologies or strategic business skills, and the Internal Mobility Rate (employees moving into more strategic or technology-focused roles) can signal a proactive approach to workforce adaptation. A lack of investment in these areas, even with automation implementation, might suggest a more superficial adoption, rather than a deep cultural integration.

Metrics that truly indicate an automation cultural shift move beyond simple efficiency, revealing changes in employee roles, customer experience, innovation speed, and workforce development.

Practical SMB Implementation

For a small business owner, tracking these metrics doesn’t require complex systems. Simple spreadsheets and regular check-ins with employees can provide valuable insights. For example, track the time spent on specific tasks before and after automation. Solicit regular customer feedback Meaning ● Customer Feedback, within the landscape of SMBs, represents the vital information conduit channeling insights, opinions, and reactions from customers pertaining to products, services, or the overall brand experience; it is strategically used to inform and refine business decisions related to growth, automation initiatives, and operational implementations. through short surveys or informal conversations.

Observe how employees are spending their time and whether they are taking on new responsibilities. Are they suggesting new ideas? Are they learning new skills? These qualitative and quantitative observations, combined with a focus on the right metrics, can reveal whether automation is simply a tool being used, or a catalyst for a deeper, more transformative cultural shift within the SMB.

Initial Steps for Cultural Measurement

To begin measuring the cultural shift towards automation, SMBs can take several practical initial steps. These steps are designed to be low-cost and easily integrated into existing workflows.

1. Baseline Task Time Measurement ● Before implementing any automation, track the average time employees spend on key repetitive tasks, such as invoice processing, data entry, or customer service inquiries. This baseline will serve as a point of comparison.
2. Employee Time Allocation Logs ● Introduce simple weekly logs where employees briefly note how they are spending their time. Categorize time spent on routine tasks versus strategic or creative tasks. This provides a direct view of time allocation shifts.
3. Regular Customer Feedback Collection ● Implement a consistent method for gathering customer feedback. This could be through short post-interaction surveys, online review monitoring, or even informal phone calls. Focus on satisfaction levels and perceived responsiveness.
4. Innovation Idea Tracking ● Create a simple system for employees to submit new ideas or suggestions. Track the number of ideas submitted and, more importantly, the number that are tested or implemented. This reflects the level of employee engagement in innovation.
5. Training Participation Records ● Keep records of employee participation Meaning ● Employee participation in SMBs is strategically involving employees in decision-making and processes to leverage their insights for business growth and innovation. in any training or skill development activities, especially those related to technology or new business processes. This shows investment in workforce adaptation.

Example Metrics in Action

Consider a small e-commerce business that automates its order processing and shipping logistics. Initially, they might focus on metrics like Orders Processed Per Hour and Shipping Cost Per Order. These are important operational metrics. However, to understand the cultural shift, they should also track:

• Time Spent on Customer Engagement ● Has the sales team increased their proactive outreach to customers, now that they spend less time on order fulfillment Meaning ● Order fulfillment, within the realm of SMB growth, automation, and implementation, signifies the complete process from when a customer places an order to when they receive it, encompassing warehousing, picking, packing, shipping, and delivery. issues?
• Customer Satisfaction with Delivery Speed and Accuracy ● Are customers reporting higher satisfaction with the automated shipping process?
• Number of New Product Line Ideas Generated by Employees ● Are employees using their freed-up time to brainstorm new product offerings?
• Employee Enrollment in Digital Marketing Training ● Are employees seeking to develop skills relevant to leveraging the efficiencies gained through automation?

By tracking these broader metrics, the e-commerce business gains a more holistic understanding of automation’s impact, moving beyond simple efficiency gains Meaning ● Efficiency Gains, within the context of Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), represent the quantifiable improvements in operational productivity and resource utilization realized through strategic initiatives such as automation and process optimization. to assess its influence on culture and strategic direction.

Metrics Table for SMB Automation Cultural Shift

This table summarizes key metrics for SMBs to track, categorized by the area of business they reflect.

In essence, understanding the cultural shift towards automation in SMBs requires a move beyond traditional efficiency metrics. It demands a broader perspective that encompasses employee roles, customer experience, innovation, and workforce development. By tracking the right metrics, SMBs can ensure that automation is not just making them faster, but also smarter, more agile, and ultimately, more successful in the long run.

Intermediate

The spreadsheet showcasing reduced invoice processing times looks impressive, but it only whispers a fraction of the automation story within a maturing SMB. The true narrative of automation’s cultural impact unfolds in the less obvious metrics, those that reveal how deeply automation is reshaping strategic thinking and operational agility, not just trimming minutes from mundane tasks. Moving beyond basic efficiency, we must examine metrics that expose the evolving relationship between human capital and automated systems, a relationship that defines the modern, adaptable SMB.

Operational Agility and Response Time

Operational agility, a concept often discussed but less frequently quantified, becomes a critical metric in an automation-infused SMB. Consider Cycle Time Compression across key business processes. This goes beyond simply measuring individual task efficiency. It examines how automation reduces the end-to-end time for critical workflows, such as order fulfillment, product development iterations, or even marketing campaign deployment.

A significant reduction in these cycle times indicates a more responsive and agile organization, one where automation is not just speeding up tasks, but fundamentally accelerating the entire business rhythm. This acceleration is a hallmark of cultural integration, signifying automation’s role in strategic responsiveness.

Data-Driven Decision Making

Automation generates data, but a cultural shift occurs when this data actively informs decision-making at all levels of the SMB. Metrics related to Data Utilization in Decision Processes become paramount. Track the frequency with which data from automated systems (CRM, marketing automation, operational dashboards) is referenced in management meetings, strategic planning sessions, and even day-to-day operational adjustments.

An increase in data-backed decisions, rather than gut-feeling judgments, signals a cultural evolution. This indicates that the SMB is not just automating tasks, but also cultivating a data-driven mindset, leveraging automation’s data exhaust to steer the business strategically.

Employee Empowerment and Autonomy

Automation, paradoxically, can empower employees, fostering greater autonomy and ownership. Metrics like Employee-Initiated Process Improvements and Decentralized Decision-Making can reveal this shift. Observe if employees, freed from routine tasks, are proactively identifying and implementing process improvements, leveraging automated systems to enhance their own workflows.

Similarly, track the level of decision-making authority delegated to teams and individuals, facilitated by the real-time data and insights provided by automation. Increased employee initiative and autonomy, driven by automation-enabled insights, suggests a culture where automation is not seen as a replacement for human input, but as a tool to amplify human capabilities and distribute responsibility.

Scalability and Growth Capacity

A key strategic advantage of automation is scalability. Metrics that reflect Scalable Growth Capacity become crucial indicators of cultural impact. Examine the Revenue Growth Rate Per Employee. If revenue is scaling at a faster rate than headcount growth, it suggests that automation is enabling the SMB to achieve more with its existing human resources.

Similarly, analyze the Cost of Customer Acquisition (CAC) as the business scales. If CAC remains stable or decreases despite growth, automation is likely playing a role in efficient customer onboarding and service delivery. These metrics reveal whether automation is not just improving current operations, but also building a foundation for sustainable, scalable growth, a strategic cultural shift in ambition and operational capability.

Integration Across Business Functions

Automation’s cultural impact is amplified when it transcends departmental silos and integrates across various business functions. Metrics related to Cross-Functional Process Efficiency become important. Analyze workflows that span multiple departments, such as the sales-to-service handoff, or the marketing-to-sales lead qualification process.

If automation is streamlining these cross-functional processes, reducing friction and improving communication, it indicates a holistic cultural shift. This suggests that the SMB is not just automating individual tasks in isolation, but is strategically leveraging automation to create a more interconnected and efficient organizational ecosystem.

Risk Mitigation and Compliance

Beyond efficiency and growth, automation contributes to risk mitigation Meaning ● Within the dynamic landscape of SMB growth, automation, and implementation, Risk Mitigation denotes the proactive business processes designed to identify, assess, and strategically reduce potential threats to organizational goals. and compliance. Metrics like Compliance Incident Reduction and Audit Readiness Scores can reveal this less-discussed aspect of cultural impact. If automation is reducing compliance errors, improving data security, and making audits smoother, it signals a culture that values risk management and operational rigor. This indicates that the SMB is not just pursuing automation for cost savings or speed, but also as a strategic tool to enhance reliability, reduce vulnerabilities, and build a more robust and trustworthy business.

Intermediate metrics of automation cultural shift focus on operational agility, data-driven decisions, employee empowerment, scalable growth, cross-functional integration, and risk mitigation.

Advanced SMB Implementation

For SMBs seeking to leverage these intermediate metrics, a more sophisticated approach to data collection and analysis is required. This involves integrating data from various automated systems and establishing robust reporting mechanisms.

Refined Data Collection Strategies

To effectively track intermediate metrics, SMBs need to refine their data collection strategies. This moves beyond basic tracking to integrated data systems.

1. Integrated Data Platforms ● Implement or leverage existing platforms that integrate data from various automated systems (CRM, ERP, marketing automation, etc.). This centralizes data for comprehensive analysis.
2. Customizable Dashboards ● Create dynamic dashboards that visualize key intermediate metrics in real-time. These dashboards should be customizable to track specific workflows and departmental performance.
3. Automated Reporting ● Set up automated reporting schedules to regularly generate reports on key metrics. This ensures consistent monitoring and timely identification of trends.
4. Process Mapping and Analysis Tools ● Utilize process mapping software to visualize end-to-end workflows and identify bottlenecks. Automation analysis tools can then pinpoint areas for optimization and measure cycle time compression.
5. Employee Feedback Systems (Advanced) ● Implement more structured employee feedback mechanisms, such as regular surveys focused on autonomy, process improvement suggestions, and data utilization in their roles.

Example Metrics in Action (Intermediate)

Consider a mid-sized manufacturing SMB that has implemented automation across its production line, supply chain management, and customer relationship management. Beyond basic efficiency metrics, they should monitor:

• Order-To-Delivery Cycle Time ● How much has the entire order fulfillment process been compressed, from initial order placement to final delivery?
• Data-Driven Decisions in Production Scheduling ● Are production schedules being dynamically adjusted based on real-time data from automated production sensors and demand forecasts?
• Number of Employee-Led Process Automation Initiatives ● Are employees on the production floor suggesting and implementing automation improvements within their own workflows?
• Revenue Growth Per Employee in Manufacturing ● Is revenue scaling faster than headcount in the manufacturing department, indicating automation-driven productivity gains?
• Cross-Departmental Communication Efficiency ● Has communication and data flow improved between production, sales, and customer service departments due to integrated automation systems?
• Reduction in Production Error-Related Compliance Incidents ● Are automated quality control systems reducing compliance violations related to product defects?

Metrics Table for Intermediate SMB Automation Cultural Shift

This table expands on the previous table, focusing on intermediate metrics for a deeper understanding of automation’s cultural impact in SMBs.

Moving beyond basic efficiency, intermediate metrics offer a more strategic lens through which SMBs can assess the cultural impact of automation. These metrics reveal how automation is reshaping organizational agility, decision-making, employee roles, growth trajectory, and risk management. By tracking these indicators, SMBs can ensure that their automation investments are not just yielding operational improvements, but also fostering a more adaptable, data-driven, and strategically robust business culture, ready for sustained success in an increasingly automated world.

Advanced

Beyond the dashboards displaying cycle time compression and revenue per employee, a deeper, almost imperceptible, transformation occurs within organizations genuinely embracing automation. The subtle yet profound shift in organizational culture, driven by sophisticated automation implementation, is reflected in metrics that transcend operational improvements and strategic advantages. These advanced metrics delve into the very epistemology of the business, revealing how automation reshapes organizational cognition, fosters emergent behaviors, and ultimately redefines the human-machine symbiosis at the core of competitive advantage. This is where automation ceases to be a tool and becomes a foundational element of organizational identity.

Cognitive Load Distribution and Organizational Learning

In advanced automation Meaning ● Advanced Automation, in the context of Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), signifies the strategic implementation of sophisticated technologies that move beyond basic task automation to drive significant improvements in business processes, operational efficiency, and scalability. scenarios, the distribution of cognitive load Meaning ● Cognitive Load, in the context of SMB growth and automation, represents the total mental effort required to process information impacting decision-making and operational efficiency. within the organization undergoes a fundamental shift. Metrics related to Cognitive Task Allocation between humans and machines become critical. Analyze the types of tasks increasingly delegated to automated systems ● are they primarily routine and transactional, or are they encroaching upon areas previously considered the domain of human expertise, such as complex analysis, pattern recognition, or even creative problem-solving? Furthermore, assess Organizational Learning Velocity.

Is the organization learning and adapting at a faster pace due to the insights generated by automated systems and the freed-up cognitive bandwidth of human employees? Metrics like the Time to Market for New, Complex Products or Services or the Rate of Successful Strategic Pivots can reflect this accelerated learning. A shift towards machines handling increasingly complex cognitive tasks, coupled with an increase in organizational learning Meaning ● Organizational Learning: SMB's continuous improvement through experience, driving growth and adaptability. velocity, signifies a profound cultural transformation, where automation is not just augmenting human capabilities, but reshaping the very cognitive architecture of the business.

Emergent System Behaviors and Network Effects

Advanced automation systems, particularly those incorporating AI and machine learning, can exhibit emergent behaviors, creating network effects Meaning ● Network Effects, in the context of SMB growth, refer to a phenomenon where the value of a company's product or service increases as more users join the network. that amplify organizational capabilities in unexpected ways. Metrics focused on Emergent System Performance and Network Value Creation become essential. Track metrics that capture synergistic outcomes arising from the interplay of automated systems and human interactions. For example, in a customer service context, analyze Customer Lifetime Value (CLTV) Uplift attributable to AI-powered personalized interactions and proactive service interventions.

In supply chain management, assess Supply Chain Resilience Metrics, such as the ability to withstand disruptions and adapt to unforeseen events, enhanced by automated predictive analytics and adaptive routing algorithms. These metrics reveal how automation is not just optimizing individual processes, but creating emergent system-level advantages, generating network effects that propel the organization beyond the sum of its parts. This emergence signifies a cultural embrace of complexity and a recognition of automation as a catalyst for organizational evolution.

Human-Machine Collaboration and Trust Dynamics

The success of advanced automation hinges on effective human-machine collaboration, which in turn is underpinned by trust. Metrics related to Human-Machine Trust Calibration and Collaborative Workflow Efficiency become paramount. Assess employee trust Meaning ● Employee trust, within the SMB context, is the degree to which employees believe in the integrity, reliability, and fairness of their organization and leadership. levels in automated systems through surveys and qualitative feedback. Are employees confident in the reliability and accuracy of automated insights and recommendations?

Are they willing to delegate critical decision-making authority to automated systems in appropriate contexts? Furthermore, analyze Collaborative Workflow Optimization Metrics. Are human-machine workflows designed for seamless interaction and mutual reinforcement? Are automated systems providing humans with timely and relevant information to enhance their decision-making, and vice versa?

Metrics like Time Spent on Human-Machine Collaborative Tasks and Perceived Effectiveness of Human-Machine Teams can reveal the quality of this collaboration. A culture of high human-machine trust and optimized collaborative workflows indicates a mature and sophisticated approach to automation, where the focus is not on replacing humans, but on creating synergistic partnerships that amplify collective intelligence.

Ethical and Responsible Automation Metrics

As automation becomes deeply integrated into organizational processes, ethical considerations become increasingly important. Metrics related to Algorithmic Fairness and Bias Detection and Transparency and Explainability of Automated Decisions become critical indicators of a responsible automation Meaning ● Responsible Automation for SMBs means ethically deploying tech to boost growth, considering stakeholder impact and long-term values. culture. Track metrics that assess potential biases in automated decision-making systems, particularly in areas with significant human impact, such as hiring, promotion, or customer service interactions. Implement audit trails and transparency mechanisms to ensure that automated decisions are explainable and accountable.

Metrics like Bias Detection Rates in AI Algorithms and Percentage of Automated Decisions with Documented Explainability reflect an organization’s commitment to ethical and responsible automation practices. This ethical dimension signifies a cultural maturity, where automation is not pursued blindly, but with careful consideration of its societal and human implications.

Adaptive Organizational Structure and Role Evolution

Advanced automation necessitates an adaptive organizational structure and a continuous evolution of human roles. Metrics related to Organizational Structural Fluidity and Role Redefinition Velocity become indicators of cultural agility. Assess the organization’s ability to adapt its structure and workflows in response to evolving automation capabilities and changing business needs. Track the Frequency of Organizational Restructuring Initiatives and the Rate of Job Role Evolution.

Are job roles being continuously redefined to leverage human strengths in areas where automation is less effective, such as creativity, emotional intelligence, and complex interpersonal interactions? An organization that embraces structural fluidity and role evolution, continuously adapting to the changing landscape of automation, demonstrates a future-oriented and culturally agile approach, prepared to thrive in a dynamic and automated world.

Advanced metrics of automation cultural shift explore cognitive load distribution, emergent system behaviors, human-machine trust, ethical automation, and adaptive organizational structures.

Corporate Strategy and SMB Growth Integration

For SMBs aspiring to leverage advanced automation for strategic growth, integrating these metrics into corporate strategy becomes paramount. This requires a shift from tactical implementation to strategic orchestration of automation initiatives.

Strategic Automation Framework

To effectively integrate advanced metrics, SMBs need to adopt a strategic automation framework Meaning ● A structured approach for SMBs to strategically implement automation for efficiency, growth, and competitive advantage. that aligns automation initiatives Meaning ● Automation Initiatives, in the context of SMB growth, represent structured efforts to implement technologies that reduce manual intervention in business processes. with overarching business goals.

1. Strategic Alignment Mapping ● Develop a framework that maps automation initiatives to specific strategic objectives, such as market expansion, product innovation, or customer experience Meaning ● Customer Experience for SMBs: Holistic, subjective customer perception across all interactions, driving loyalty and growth. differentiation.
2. Advanced Metric Integration into KPIs ● Incorporate advanced metrics, such as cognitive task allocation, emergent system performance, and human-machine trust, into key performance indicators (KPIs) at both departmental and organizational levels.
3. Cross-Functional Automation Steering Committees ● Establish cross-functional committees responsible for overseeing automation strategy, monitoring advanced metrics, and ensuring alignment with corporate goals.
4. Continuous Automation Strategy Meaning ● Strategic tech integration to boost SMB efficiency and growth. Review Cycles ● Implement regular review cycles to assess the effectiveness of automation strategy, analyze advanced metric trends, and adapt automation initiatives to evolving business needs and technological advancements.
5. Ethical Automation Governance Framework ● Develop a formal governance framework for ethical automation, incorporating bias detection protocols, transparency guidelines, and accountability mechanisms, with regular audits and reviews.

Example Metrics in Action (Advanced)

Consider a rapidly scaling tech SMB that is leveraging AI-driven automation across its product development, marketing, and customer support Meaning ● Customer Support, in the context of SMB growth strategies, represents a critical function focused on fostering customer satisfaction and loyalty to drive business expansion. functions. To assess the advanced cultural shift, they should monitor:

• Cognitive Load Shift in Product Development ● Are AI-powered tools handling increasingly complex tasks in software coding, testing, and design, freeing up human developers for higher-level architectural and strategic tasks?
• Emergent Market Insights from AI-Driven Marketing ● Is the AI marketing system generating unexpected but valuable insights into customer behavior and market trends, leading to novel marketing strategies?
• Human-Machine Trust in Customer Support ● Are customer support agents increasingly relying on AI-powered recommendations and insights to resolve complex customer issues, and is customer satisfaction improving as a result?
• Algorithmic Fairness in AI-Driven Hiring ● Are bias detection metrics being used to ensure fairness and diversity in AI-powered candidate screening and selection processes?
• Organizational Restructuring Frequency in Response to Automation ● How often is the organization adapting its structure and roles to optimize human-machine collaboration Meaning ● Strategic blend of human skills & machine intelligence for SMB growth and innovation. and leverage new automation capabilities?

Metrics Table for Advanced SMB Automation Cultural Shift

This table summarizes advanced metrics for SMBs seeking to understand the deepest cultural transformations driven by sophisticated automation.

Advanced metrics offer a profound understanding of automation’s cultural impact, moving beyond operational and strategic considerations to reveal transformations in organizational cognition, emergent behaviors, human-machine dynamics, ethical responsibility, and structural agility. For SMBs aiming for sustained competitive advantage in the age of intelligent automation, these metrics are not merely indicators, but essential navigational tools, guiding them towards a future where humans and machines collaborate synergistically to achieve unprecedented levels of innovation, resilience, and ethical business practice. The journey is not about simply implementing technology; it is about cultivating a culture that thrives in symbiotic partnership with intelligent systems, a culture measured not just in efficiency gains, but in the very evolution of organizational intelligence.

References

• Brynjolfsson, Erik, and Andrew McAfee. The Second Machine Age ● Work, Progress, and Prosperity in a Time of Brilliant Technologies. W. W. Norton & Company, 2014.
• Davenport, Thomas H., and Julia Kirby. Only Humans Need Apply ● Winners and Losers in the Age of Smart Machines. Harper Business, 2016.
• Manyika, James, et al. A Future That Works ● Automation, Employment, and Productivity. McKinsey Global Institute, 2017.