Fundamentals

Consider this ● roughly 60% of small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) believe artificial intelligence (AI) is crucial for their future success, yet only a fraction actively measure its ethical implications. This disparity isn’t a simple oversight; it reflects a deeper tension between the perceived benefits of AI and the often-murky waters of its ethical impact. For an SMB owner juggling payroll, marketing, and supply chains, ‘ethical AI’ can sound like abstract corporate jargon, disconnected from daily realities.

However, dismissing ethical considerations as irrelevant to the bottom line is a strategic misstep, particularly as AI becomes more deeply integrated into SMB operations. The metrics used to evaluate ethical AI Meaning ● Ethical AI for SMBs means using AI responsibly to build trust, ensure fairness, and drive sustainable growth, not just for profit but for societal benefit. impact are not some separate, feel-good exercise; they are integral to sustainable growth, customer trust, and long-term profitability.

Defining Ethical AI in Practical SMB Terms

Before diving into metrics, it’s essential to ground the concept of ethical AI in a way that resonates with SMBs. Ethical AI, in this context, is not about philosophical debates; it’s about ensuring AI systems used by your business are fair, transparent, and accountable. Think of it as the digital equivalent of your business’s code of conduct. Does your AI-powered customer service chatbot treat all customers equally, regardless of their background?

Is the AI algorithm recommending products inadvertently biased against a specific demographic? These are not just abstract questions; they have tangible consequences for your business reputation and customer relationships.

For an SMB, ethical AI implementation Meaning ● Implementation in SMBs is the dynamic process of turning strategic plans into action, crucial for growth and requiring adaptability and strategic alignment. is less about grand pronouncements and more about practical steps. It starts with understanding the potential biases that can creep into AI systems, often unintentionally. Data used to train AI can reflect existing societal biases, leading to skewed outcomes.

For instance, an AI hiring tool trained on historical data that predominantly features male candidates might inadvertently disadvantage female applicants. Recognizing these potential pitfalls is the first step towards building and using AI ethically.

Ethical AI for SMBs Meaning ● SMBs are dynamic businesses, vital to economies, characterized by agility, customer focus, and innovation. is about fairness, transparency, and accountability in AI systems, directly impacting customer trust Meaning ● Customer trust for SMBs is the confident reliance customers have in your business to consistently deliver value, act ethically, and responsibly use technology. and long-term profitability.

Core Business Metrics Reimagined for Ethical AI

The beauty of evaluating ethical AI impact is that it doesn’t require inventing entirely new metrics. Instead, it involves reframing and expanding existing business metrics to incorporate ethical dimensions. Metrics that SMBs already track, such as customer satisfaction, employee retention, and brand reputation, can be powerful indicators of ethical AI performance when viewed through an ethical lens. Let’s explore how some familiar metrics can be repurposed.

Customer Satisfaction and Fairness

Customer satisfaction (CSAT) is a staple metric for any SMB. However, when evaluating ethical AI, CSAT needs to be examined for disparities across different customer segments. If your AI-driven personalization engine consistently offers better deals or service to one demographic over another, it may boost overall CSAT but mask underlying ethical issues. The key is to segment CSAT data and analyze whether AI systems are contributing to equitable customer experiences.

For example, consider an e-commerce SMB using AI to recommend products. If analysis reveals that the AI consistently recommends higher-priced items to customers from lower-income zip codes, while offering discounts to wealthier areas, this raises immediate ethical red flags. While seemingly maximizing short-term revenue, such practices erode customer trust and can lead to negative word-of-mouth, especially in today’s hyper-connected world. Ethical CSAT, therefore, is not just about overall scores but about equitable satisfaction across all customer groups.

Employee Retention and Algorithmic Transparency

Employee retention is another critical metric for SMBs, directly impacting operational stability and costs. As AI increasingly influences HR processes, from recruitment to performance evaluations, ethical considerations become paramount. If AI algorithms used for employee monitoring or performance reviews are perceived as opaque or unfair, it can significantly damage employee morale and drive up turnover rates.

Imagine an SMB using AI-powered software to track employee productivity. If employees feel they are being judged by a black box algorithm they don’t understand, and if they perceive the system as biased or overly intrusive, job satisfaction will plummet. Ethical AI in HR means ensuring algorithmic transparency Meaning ● Operating openly and honestly to build trust and drive sustainable SMB growth. ● explaining to employees how AI systems work, what data they use, and how decisions are made. Metrics like employee turnover, absenteeism, and internal surveys on workplace fairness can serve as barometers of ethical AI implementation in HR.

Brand Reputation and Responsible Automation

Brand reputation is an intangible yet invaluable asset for SMBs. In the age of social media and instant information dissemination, a single ethical misstep involving AI can trigger a reputational crisis. Consider the impact of an AI chatbot that provides biased or discriminatory responses, or an automated marketing campaign that inadvertently targets vulnerable populations with inappropriate offers. These scenarios can quickly tarnish a brand’s image, especially for SMBs that rely heavily on local community trust.

Monitoring brand sentiment through social media listening, online reviews, and customer feedback becomes crucial for gauging the ethical impact of AI. Negative mentions or complaints specifically related to AI-driven interactions should be treated as serious warning signs. Proactive communication about your SMB’s commitment to ethical AI, along with transparent practices, can mitigate reputational risks and even enhance brand value in a market increasingly conscious of ethical business conduct.

Practical Steps for SMBs to Implement Ethical AI Metrics

Implementing ethical AI metrics Meaning ● Quantifiable measures ensuring AI systems in SMBs are fair, transparent, and accountable, fostering trust and sustainable growth. doesn’t need to be a complex or expensive undertaking for SMBs. It’s about integrating ethical considerations into existing business processes and using readily available tools. Here are some practical steps ●

1. Conduct an Ethical AI Audit ● Start by assessing your current and planned AI applications for potential ethical risks. This doesn’t require hiring expensive consultants. Simply gather your team and brainstorm potential areas where AI could inadvertently introduce bias or unfairness. Focus on areas like customer interactions, marketing, and HR.
2. Segment and Analyze Existing Data ● Re-examine your customer data, employee data, and performance metrics through an ethical lens. Segment data by relevant demographics (e.g., gender, age, location) and look for disparities in outcomes or satisfaction levels that might be linked to AI systems.
3. Establish Transparency and Feedback Loops ● Communicate clearly with customers and employees about how AI is being used in your business. Provide channels for feedback and actively solicit input on fairness and transparency. This could be as simple as adding a feedback section to your website or conducting regular employee surveys.
4. Focus on Continuous Monitoring and Improvement ● Ethical AI is not a one-time project; it’s an ongoing process. Regularly monitor your ethical AI metrics, review feedback, and make adjustments as needed. Treat ethical AI as an iterative process of learning and improvement, just like any other aspect of your business.

SMBs can integrate ethical AI metrics by auditing AI applications, segmenting data, ensuring transparency, and continuously monitoring for improvements.

By integrating these metrics into their operations, SMBs can not only mitigate ethical risks but also unlock new opportunities. Ethical AI is not a constraint; it’s a competitive advantage. Businesses that prioritize fairness, transparency, and accountability in their AI systems are more likely to build lasting customer loyalty, attract top talent, and cultivate a strong, trustworthy brand. The metrics are not just about measuring ethics; they are about measuring sustainable business success in the age of AI.

The journey towards ethical AI is ongoing, but for SMBs, taking the first step ● reimagining existing metrics ● is a powerful way to begin. It’s a step that aligns ethical responsibility with sound business strategy, paving the way for a future where AI benefits everyone, fairly and equitably.

Navigating Ethical AI Metrics Complexities

The initial embrace of AI by SMBs often focuses on efficiency gains and cost reduction, overlooking the intricate ethical landscape that accompanies advanced algorithms. While basic metrics like customer satisfaction Meaning ● Customer Satisfaction: Ensuring customer delight by consistently meeting and exceeding expectations, fostering loyalty and advocacy. and employee retention Meaning ● Employee retention for SMBs is strategically fostering an environment where valued employees choose to stay, contributing to sustained business growth. offer a starting point, a more sophisticated understanding of ethical AI impact requires delving into metrics that capture the nuances of algorithmic bias, data privacy, and accountability. For SMBs aiming for sustainable growth Meaning ● Growth for SMBs is the sustainable amplification of value through strategic adaptation and capability enhancement in a dynamic market. and competitive differentiation, ethical AI is not a peripheral concern but a core strategic imperative demanding rigorous measurement and management.

Beyond Surface Metrics ● Unpacking Algorithmic Bias

Algorithmic bias represents a significant ethical challenge in AI deployment, particularly for SMBs that may lack the resources for extensive bias testing. Bias can creep into AI systems at various stages, from data collection and preprocessing to algorithm design and deployment. Simply monitoring overall customer satisfaction may not reveal subtle but significant biases affecting specific customer segments. Intermediate-level ethical AI metrics need to focus on identifying and quantifying algorithmic bias Meaning ● Algorithmic bias in SMBs: unfair outcomes from automated systems due to flawed data or design. to ensure fairness and equity.

One crucial metric is Disparate Impact Analysis. This involves examining whether an AI system disproportionately affects certain demographic groups. For instance, if an SMB uses AI for loan application processing, disparate impact analysis would assess if the AI system denies loans at a higher rate to applicants from specific racial or ethnic backgrounds, even when controlling for other relevant factors. Quantifying disparate impact requires segmenting data and comparing outcomes across different groups, using statistical measures to detect significant disparities.

Another valuable metric is Fairness through Awareness. This principle emphasizes the need for AI systems to be aware of and account for sensitive attributes like race, gender, or religion when making decisions. Metrics in this area focus on measuring the extent to which AI systems are designed and trained to mitigate bias related to these attributes. For example, in an AI-powered recruitment tool, metrics could track the representation of diverse candidates at each stage of the hiring process, ensuring the AI is not inadvertently filtering out qualified individuals from underrepresented groups.

Disparate impact analysis and fairness through awareness are crucial metrics for SMBs to quantify and mitigate algorithmic bias in AI systems.

Data Privacy and Security as Ethical Imperatives

Data privacy and security are not merely compliance issues; they are fundamental ethical considerations in the age of AI. SMBs often handle sensitive customer data, and AI systems rely heavily on data for training and operation. Breaches of data privacy Meaning ● Data privacy for SMBs is the responsible handling of personal data to build trust and enable sustainable business growth. or misuse of personal information can have devastating ethical and business consequences, eroding customer trust and leading to legal repercussions. Ethical AI metrics must therefore encompass robust measures of data privacy and security Meaning ● Data privacy, in the realm of SMB growth, refers to the establishment of policies and procedures protecting sensitive customer and company data from unauthorized access or misuse; this is not merely compliance, but building customer trust. practices.

Data Minimization is a key principle of ethical data handling. Metrics related to data minimization track the amount of personal data collected, processed, and stored by an SMB’s AI systems. The goal is to minimize data collection to only what is strictly necessary for the intended purpose, reducing the risk of privacy breaches and misuse. Metrics could include the percentage of customer data fields actively used by AI algorithms versus total data collected, or the duration of data retention periods.

Differential Privacy is an advanced technique to protect individual privacy while still enabling data analysis. Metrics for differential privacy assess the degree to which AI systems are designed to prevent re-identification of individuals from aggregated data. This involves adding statistical noise to data to obscure individual records while preserving overall data patterns. While technically complex, understanding and implementing differential privacy principles, even in simplified forms, can significantly enhance the ethical posture of SMB AI applications.

Furthermore, Data Security Breach Frequency and Severity remain critical metrics. While not unique to AI, the increasing reliance on AI systems to process vast amounts of data amplifies the potential impact of security breaches. Metrics should track the number of security incidents, the types of data compromised, and the time taken to detect and resolve breaches. Investing in robust cybersecurity measures and regularly monitoring these metrics is an ethical imperative for SMBs deploying AI.

Accountability and Explainability in AI Decision-Making

Accountability and explainability are essential pillars of ethical AI, particularly as AI systems become more autonomous and influential in business decisions. For SMBs, understanding how AI systems arrive at conclusions and ensuring human oversight are crucial for maintaining trust and control. Ethical AI metrics in this domain focus on transparency and the ability to trace and understand AI decision-making processes.

Model Explainability metrics assess the degree to which AI models are interpretable and understandable. Black-box AI models, while potentially highly accurate, can be opaque in their decision-making processes, making it difficult to identify biases or errors. Metrics like feature importance scores, decision tree visualization complexity, and the use of explainable AI (XAI) techniques quantify the level of model interpretability. SMBs should prioritize using AI models and techniques that offer a reasonable degree of explainability, especially in high-stakes applications.

Auditability is another critical aspect of accountability. Metrics for auditability track the extent to which AI systems and their decision-making processes can be independently audited and verified. This includes logging AI system inputs, outputs, and internal states, as well as establishing clear protocols for human review and intervention. Regular audits of AI systems, focusing on ethical compliance and performance, are essential for maintaining accountability and identifying areas for improvement.

Human-In-The-Loop Metrics measure the degree of human oversight and control in AI-driven processes. In many SMB applications, a fully automated AI system may not be desirable or ethically sound. Metrics could track the frequency of human review of AI decisions, the types of decisions requiring human approval, and the effectiveness of human intervention mechanisms. Striking the right balance between automation Meaning ● Automation for SMBs: Strategically using technology to streamline tasks, boost efficiency, and drive growth. and human oversight is crucial for responsible AI implementation.

Implementing Advanced Ethical AI Metrics ● A Phased Approach for SMBs

Implementing these more advanced ethical AI metrics requires a structured, phased approach, particularly for SMBs with limited resources. Here’s a practical roadmap ●

1. Prioritize High-Risk AI Applications ● Focus initial efforts on AI applications that pose the highest ethical risks, such as those involving sensitive customer data, critical decision-making, or potential for bias. For example, if an SMB uses AI for credit scoring or fraud detection, these areas should be prioritized for ethical metric implementation.
2. Leverage Existing Data Analytics Tools ● Many SMBs already use data analytics tools for business intelligence. These tools can often be adapted to calculate ethical AI metrics like disparate impact or data minimization. Explore the capabilities of your existing software before investing in specialized ethical AI platforms.
3. Seek Expert Guidance Strategically ● While SMBs may not need full-time ethical AI experts, targeted consultation can be invaluable. Engage with ethical AI consultants or researchers for specific tasks like bias audits or data privacy assessments. Focus on obtaining actionable insights and practical recommendations.
4. Build Internal Ethical AI Awareness ● Invest in training and education to raise ethical AI awareness among your team. This doesn’t require deep technical expertise but rather a shared understanding of ethical principles and potential risks. Empower employees to identify and report ethical concerns related to AI.

SMBs can implement advanced ethical AI metrics by prioritizing high-risk applications, leveraging existing tools, seeking strategic expert guidance, and building internal awareness.

By adopting a more nuanced and metric-driven approach to ethical AI, SMBs can move beyond superficial considerations and build AI systems that are not only efficient but also fair, transparent, and accountable. This deeper commitment to ethical AI is not just about risk mitigation; it’s about building a sustainable competitive advantage Meaning ● SMB Competitive Advantage: Ecosystem-embedded, hyper-personalized value, sustained by strategic automation, ensuring resilience & impact. in a market increasingly valuing ethical business practices. As AI becomes more pervasive, SMBs that proactively address ethical challenges will be better positioned to build customer trust, attract and retain talent, and foster long-term growth.

The journey to ethical AI maturity is a continuous evolution, and for SMBs, embracing advanced metrics is a crucial step towards navigating the complexities and realizing the full potential of responsible AI innovation. It’s about transforming ethical aspirations into measurable actions, ensuring that AI serves as a force for good, both for the business and for society.

Strategic Integration of Ethical AI Metrics for SMB Growth and Automation

For SMBs poised for exponential growth and leveraging AI for deep automation, ethical AI is no longer a compliance checkbox but a strategic differentiator, deeply interwoven with long-term value creation. Advanced ethical AI metrics transcend simple bias detection and privacy safeguards; they become instruments for shaping organizational culture, driving innovation, and fostering a competitive edge in an increasingly ethically conscious marketplace. At this level, ethical AI metrics are not merely reactive measures but proactive tools for guiding strategic decision-making and ensuring AI alignment with core business values and societal expectations.

Ethical AI as a Driver of Innovation and Competitive Advantage

Contrary to the misconception that ethical considerations stifle innovation, a robust ethical AI framework can actually fuel it. By embedding ethical metrics into the AI development lifecycle, SMBs can identify and mitigate potential risks early on, fostering trust and confidence in their AI solutions. This proactive approach can unlock new avenues for innovation, particularly in areas where ethical considerations are paramount, such as personalized healthcare, inclusive finance, and sustainable resource management.

Ethical Innovation Metrics assess the extent to which ethical considerations are integrated into the AI innovation process. This includes tracking the implementation of ethical design principles, the use of ethical AI frameworks (e.g., fairness checklists, privacy-preserving techniques), and the involvement of ethicists or diverse stakeholders in AI development. Metrics could also measure the number of AI projects explicitly addressing ethical challenges or the percentage of R&D budget allocated to ethical AI research. SMBs that actively measure and promote ethical innovation are more likely to develop AI solutions that are not only technically advanced but also socially responsible and market-leading.

Competitive Differentiation Metrics quantify the extent to which ethical AI practices Meaning ● Ethical AI Practices, concerning SMB growth, relate to implementing AI systems fairly, transparently, and accountably, fostering trust among stakeholders and users. contribute to a competitive advantage. In today’s market, consumers and businesses increasingly value ethical and sustainable products and services. SMBs that can demonstrably showcase their commitment to ethical AI can attract ethically conscious customers, partners, and investors.

Metrics could track customer acquisition rates among ethically motivated segments, brand perception scores related to ethical AI, and investor interest in ethically aligned AI ventures. Ethical AI, when strategically measured and communicated, becomes a powerful differentiator in a crowded marketplace.

Ethical innovation metrics and competitive differentiation metrics demonstrate how ethical AI practices can drive innovation and create a competitive edge for SMBs.

Measuring the ROI of Ethical AI Investments

Quantifying the return on investment (ROI) of ethical AI initiatives is crucial for justifying resource allocation and demonstrating the business value of ethical practices. While the benefits of ethical AI may not always be immediately apparent in traditional financial metrics, a broader perspective on ROI, encompassing reputational capital, risk mitigation, and long-term sustainability, reveals the significant value proposition of ethical AI investments.

Risk Mitigation Metrics assess the extent to which ethical AI practices reduce potential risks and liabilities. Unethical AI practices can lead to regulatory fines, legal challenges, reputational damage, and loss of customer trust. Metrics could track the reduction in ethical AI-related incidents (e.g., bias complaints, privacy breaches), the decrease in legal and compliance costs, and the improvement in risk management ratings. By proactively addressing ethical risks through measured practices, SMBs can avoid costly downstream consequences and enhance their long-term stability.

Reputational Capital Metrics quantify the positive impact of ethical AI on brand reputation and stakeholder trust. A strong ethical reputation is an invaluable asset, particularly in the AI era where public scrutiny of technology ethics is intensifying. Metrics could track improvements in brand sentiment scores, positive media coverage related to ethical AI initiatives, increased customer loyalty and advocacy, and enhanced employee morale and talent attraction. Reputational capital, built through demonstrable ethical AI practices, translates into tangible business benefits over time.

Long-Term Sustainability Metrics evaluate the contribution of ethical AI to the long-term viability and resilience of the SMB. Ethical AI practices align with broader sustainability goals, fostering responsible innovation and societal well-being. Metrics could track the alignment of AI strategies with sustainability frameworks (e.g., UN Sustainable Development Goals), the positive social and environmental impact of AI solutions, and the long-term customer and employee retention rates associated with ethical business practices. Ethical AI, viewed through a sustainability lens, becomes an investment in the enduring success of the SMB and its positive contribution to society.

Integrating Ethical AI Metrics into Corporate Strategy and SMB Growth

For ethical AI metrics to truly drive strategic impact, they must be seamlessly integrated into the overall corporate strategy and SMB growth Meaning ● SMB Growth is the strategic expansion of small to medium businesses focusing on sustainable value, ethical practices, and advanced automation for long-term success. plans. This requires moving beyond siloed ethical initiatives and embedding ethical considerations into every stage of the business lifecycle, from product development and marketing to operations and governance. Ethical AI metrics become key performance indicators (KPIs) at the highest levels of the organization, guiding strategic decision-making and resource allocation.

Strategic Alignment Metrics assess the degree to which ethical AI principles and metrics are integrated into the overall corporate strategy. This includes tracking the inclusion of ethical AI goals in strategic plans, the allocation of budget and resources to ethical AI initiatives, and the establishment of ethical AI governance structures at the board or executive level. Metrics could also measure the alignment of AI strategies with the company’s mission, values, and stakeholder expectations. Strategic alignment ensures that ethical AI is not a separate add-on but a core component of the SMB’s growth trajectory.

Operational Integration Metrics quantify the extent to which ethical AI metrics are embedded into day-to-day business operations. This involves tracking the use of ethical AI metrics in product development processes, marketing campaigns, customer service interactions, and HR practices. Metrics could measure the percentage of AI-driven processes incorporating ethical checks, the frequency of ethical AI audits in operational workflows, and the level of employee engagement in ethical AI initiatives. Operational integration ensures that ethical AI is not just a strategic aspiration but a lived reality across the organization.

Growth and Automation Metrics link ethical AI performance to tangible business growth and automation outcomes. This involves demonstrating how ethical AI practices contribute to increased revenue, improved efficiency, enhanced customer satisfaction, and successful automation initiatives. Metrics could track the correlation between ethical AI scores and customer lifetime value, the impact of ethical AI on employee productivity and retention in automated processes, and the contribution of ethical AI to market share growth and profitability. Growth and automation metrics provide concrete evidence of the business value of ethical AI, justifying ongoing investment and strategic prioritization.

Advanced Implementation Framework for Ethical AI Metrics

Implementing advanced ethical AI metrics requires a sophisticated framework that goes beyond basic checklists and incorporates continuous monitoring, adaptive learning, and cross-functional collaboration. For SMBs aiming for leadership in ethical AI, a comprehensive implementation framework is essential.

1. Establish an Ethical AI Governance Structure ● Create a dedicated ethical AI committee or designate a responsible executive to oversee ethical AI strategy and implementation. This structure should be cross-functional, involving representatives from technology, ethics, legal, compliance, and business units.
2. Develop a Dynamic Ethical AI Metric Dashboard ● Create a real-time dashboard that tracks key ethical AI metrics across different business functions. This dashboard should provide visualizations, alerts, and drill-down capabilities to monitor ethical AI performance and identify potential issues proactively.
3. Implement Continuous Ethical AI Monitoring and Auditing ● Establish automated monitoring systems to continuously track ethical AI metrics and trigger alerts for anomalies or deviations from ethical standards. Conduct regular ethical AI audits, both internal and external, to assess compliance and identify areas for improvement.
4. Foster a Culture of Ethical AI Awareness and Accountability ● Embed ethical AI principles into the organizational culture through training, communication, and incentive programs. Empower employees at all levels to identify and report ethical concerns related to AI and hold individuals and teams accountable for ethical AI performance.
5. Embrace Adaptive Ethical AI Learning and Improvement ● Treat ethical AI as an iterative process of learning and continuous improvement. Regularly review ethical AI metrics, analyze trends, and adapt strategies and practices based on data and feedback. Engage in ongoing research and development to stay ahead of emerging ethical AI challenges and best practices.

Advanced ethical AI metric implementation requires a robust framework encompassing governance, dynamic dashboards, continuous monitoring, cultural embedding, and adaptive learning.

By strategically integrating advanced ethical AI metrics into their corporate strategy and SMB growth plans, businesses can transform ethical considerations from a cost center into a profit center, driving innovation, enhancing competitive advantage, and fostering long-term sustainability. Ethical AI, measured and managed with sophistication, becomes a cornerstone of responsible and prosperous growth in the AI-driven future. It’s about moving beyond ethical compliance to ethical leadership, setting new standards for AI innovation and building a business legacy rooted in trust, fairness, and societal value.

The journey towards ethical AI mastery is a continuous evolution, demanding ongoing commitment, measurement, and adaptation, but the rewards ● both ethical and economic ● are substantial and enduring. It’s about shaping a future where AI empowers businesses to thrive while simultaneously advancing human well-being and societal progress, a future where ethics and innovation are not competing priorities but mutually reinforcing forces.

References

• Metcalf, Jacob, et al. “Algorithmic Accountability.” ACM SIGCAS Computers and Society, vol. 49, no. 3, 2019, pp. 1-13.
• Mittelstadt, Brent Daniel, et al. “The Ethics of Algorithms ● Current Landscape and Future Directions.” Big Data & Society, vol. 3, no. 2, 2016, pp. 1-21.
• O’Neil, Cathy. Weapons of Math Destruction ● How Big Data Increases Inequality and Threatens Democracy. Crown, 2016.
• Solan, Lawrence M. “Constitutionalizing Artificial Intelligence.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review, vol. 169, no. 5, 2021, pp. 1459-1514.