Fundamentals

Thirty-eight percent of small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) still grapple with manual data entry, a relic of pre-digital workflows that bleeds time and resources. This isn’t just about dusty filing cabinets; it’s about the daily grind of employees spending hours on tasks that software could handle in minutes. Consider the local bakery owner, spending evenings after flour-dusted days reconciling invoices by hand.

Or the plumbing contractor whose office manager is swamped with scheduling appointments across a patchwork of spreadsheets and sticky notes. These scenarios, repeated across countless SMBs, illustrate a critical point ● automation’s impact on employee roles isn’t some distant future concern; it’s a present-day necessity for survival and growth.

Understanding Automation in the SMB Context

Automation, at its core, represents the use of technology to perform tasks previously done by humans. For SMBs, this doesn’t conjure images of robot arms welding car parts on an assembly line. Instead, think of software that automatically sends email reminders to clients, or a system that updates inventory levels in real-time as sales are made.

Automation in this sphere is about streamlining operations, reducing errors, and freeing up human capital Meaning ● Human Capital is the strategic asset of employee skills and knowledge, crucial for SMB growth, especially when augmented by automation. for higher-value activities. It’s about making small teams more efficient and competitive without necessarily requiring massive overhauls or exorbitant investments.

Initial Impact ● Shifting the Sands of Daily Tasks

The most immediate effect of automation on SMB employee roles Meaning ● In Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), employee roles represent the defined positions and responsibilities individuals hold, influencing organizational structure and operational efficiency. is a shift in daily responsibilities. Routine, repetitive tasks ● the kind that often lead to employee burnout and stifle creativity ● are prime candidates for automation. Data entry, basic customer service Meaning ● Customer service, within the context of SMB growth, involves providing assistance and support to customers before, during, and after a purchase, a vital function for business survival. inquiries, report generation, and social media posting can all be handled by software tools.

This doesn’t automatically mean job losses; rather, it signifies a re-allocation of human effort. Employees are freed from the drudgery of these tasks and can be redirected towards activities that demand uniquely human skills ● problem-solving, strategic thinking, relationship building, and creative innovation.

Automation initially reshapes SMB employee roles by offloading routine tasks, allowing human capital to focus on strategic and creative endeavors.

Employee Roles Evolving Not Disappearing

A common misconception surrounding automation is that it leads to widespread job displacement. While certain roles may evolve or become redundant, the overall impact on SMBs is more about role transformation. Consider the example of a small retail store adopting a point-of-sale (POS) system with automated inventory management.

The employee who previously spent hours manually counting stock can now focus on improving customer experience, creating engaging product displays, or developing local marketing initiatives. The role hasn’t vanished; it’s been upgraded, demanding a different skillset and offering greater opportunities for employee engagement and contribution.

The Human Element Remains Paramount

Automation in SMBs isn’t about replacing humans entirely; it’s about augmenting human capabilities. Even the most sophisticated software requires human oversight, management, and adaptation. Customer interactions, particularly those requiring empathy, complex problem-solving, or personalized service, still necessitate a human touch.

Automation can handle the initial stages of customer service, such as answering frequently asked questions via chatbots, but when issues escalate or require nuanced understanding, human employees are crucial. The focus shifts from performing basic tasks to managing automated systems and handling exceptions, demanding a higher level of skill and responsibility from employees.

Navigating the Transition ● Practical Steps for SMBs

For SMB owners contemplating automation, the prospect can feel daunting. Where to begin? How to choose the right tools? How to ensure employees adapt successfully?

The key is to approach automation strategically and incrementally. Start by identifying pain points ● those repetitive, time-consuming tasks that drain employee productivity and morale. Then, research automation solutions specifically designed for SMBs, focusing on user-friendliness, scalability, and affordability. Cloud-based software-as-a-service (SaaS) solutions often provide a low-barrier entry point, with subscription models that align with SMB budget constraints.

Essential Automation Tools for SMBs

Several categories of automation tools Meaning ● Automation Tools, within the sphere of SMB growth, represent software solutions and digital instruments designed to streamline and automate repetitive business tasks, minimizing manual intervention. are particularly beneficial for SMBs:

1. Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Systems ● Automate customer data management, sales processes, and marketing campaigns.
2. Accounting Software ● Streamline invoicing, expense tracking, payroll, and financial reporting.
3. Project Management Tools ● Automate task assignment, progress tracking, and team communication.
4. Marketing Automation Platforms ● Automate email marketing, social media scheduling, and lead nurturing.
5. Human Resources (HR) Software ● Automate onboarding, payroll, benefits administration, and employee record keeping.

These tools, often designed with SMBs in mind, offer intuitive interfaces and scalable features, allowing businesses to automate key functions without requiring extensive technical expertise or upfront investment.

Employee Training and Upskilling ● A Prerequisite for Success

Implementing automation successfully requires investing in employee training Meaning ● Employee Training in SMBs is a structured process to equip employees with necessary skills and knowledge for current and future roles, driving business growth. and upskilling. As roles evolve, employees need to acquire new skills to manage automated systems, analyze data generated by these systems, and perform higher-level tasks. This might involve training in software usage, data analysis, customer service techniques, or even basic coding skills depending on the level of automation adopted. Providing employees with opportunities to learn and grow not only ensures a smooth transition but also boosts morale and fosters a culture of continuous improvement Meaning ● Ongoing, incremental improvements focused on agility and value for SMB success. within the SMB.

Addressing Employee Concerns and Fostering Buy-In

Resistance to automation from employees is a natural concern. Fear of job displacement, apprehension about learning new technologies, and a general aversion to change can create roadblocks. Open communication is crucial. SMB owners should clearly articulate the reasons for automation, emphasizing the benefits for both the business and its employees.

Highlighting how automation will alleviate tedious tasks, improve work-life balance, and create opportunities for skill development can help alleviate anxieties and foster employee buy-in. Involving employees in the automation implementation Meaning ● Strategic integration of tech to boost SMB efficiency, growth, and competitiveness. process, seeking their input, and providing ongoing support can further ease the transition and ensure a collaborative approach.

The Long View ● Automation as an Enabler of SMB Growth

In the long run, automation is not a threat to SMB employee roles but rather an enabler of SMB growth Meaning ● SMB Growth is the strategic expansion of small to medium businesses focusing on sustainable value, ethical practices, and advanced automation for long-term success. and sustainability. By automating routine tasks, SMBs can operate more efficiently, reduce costs, improve accuracy, and enhance customer service. This increased efficiency translates to greater profitability, allowing SMBs to invest in expansion, innovation, and, crucially, their employees.

Automation frees up resources that can be reinvested in hiring for specialized roles, offering better compensation and benefits, and creating a more dynamic and rewarding work environment. The impact of automation, when strategically implemented, is to elevate SMBs and their employees, positioning them for long-term success in an increasingly competitive landscape.

Strategic automation implementation within SMBs fosters growth and sustainability, ultimately benefiting both the business and its employees.

Small Business, Big Impact ● Real-World Examples

Consider a small accounting firm that automated its tax preparation process using specialized software. Initially, some employees were concerned about their roles becoming obsolete. However, the firm’s owner clearly communicated that automation would free up their time from tedious data entry and calculations, allowing them to focus on higher-value client advisory services. The firm invested in training its staff on financial planning and consulting skills.

As a result, the firm expanded its service offerings, attracted higher-paying clients, and increased overall revenue. Employees, now equipped with new skills and engaging in more strategic work, experienced increased job satisfaction and career growth. This example illustrates how automation, when coupled with strategic planning and employee development, can positively transform SMB employee roles and drive business success.

Embracing Change ● The Automation Imperative for SMBs

Automation is no longer a futuristic concept; it’s a present-day imperative for SMBs seeking to thrive. The extent of its impact on employee roles is significant, but it’s an impact of evolution, not obliteration. By strategically adopting automation, SMBs can reshape employee roles, freeing human capital from mundane tasks and empowering them to focus on higher-value, more fulfilling activities. This transition requires careful planning, investment in employee training, and open communication.

However, the rewards are substantial ● increased efficiency, improved competitiveness, sustainable growth, and a more engaged and skilled workforce. For SMBs willing to embrace change, automation is not a threat but a powerful catalyst for progress.

Strategic Automation For Evolving Smb Roles

In 2023, venture capital funding for automation-focused startups reached $15.7 billion, signaling a robust belief in automation’s transformative potential across industries, including the SMB sector. This investment isn’t solely about replacing human labor; it reflects a deeper understanding that strategic automation Meaning ● Strategic Automation: Intelligently applying tech to SMB processes for growth and efficiency. can redefine how SMBs operate and how their employees contribute. The conversation shifts from simply automating tasks to strategically leveraging automation to enhance employee roles and drive sustainable growth. For SMBs navigating this evolving landscape, a nuanced approach to automation is essential.

Beyond Task Automation ● Role Augmentation and Redesign

The intermediate stage of understanding automation’s impact moves beyond the basic premise of task replacement. It delves into role augmentation and redesign. This perspective acknowledges that automation isn’t just about eliminating jobs; it’s about reshaping them to be more strategic, creative, and human-centric. For instance, in a small marketing agency, automation tools can handle repetitive tasks like social media scheduling Meaning ● Social Media Scheduling, within the operational sphere of small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), represents the strategic process of planning and automating the distribution of content across various social media platforms. and basic email campaigns.

This frees up marketing specialists to focus on developing innovative marketing strategies, crafting compelling content, and building deeper client relationships. The role of the marketing specialist evolves from a task executor to a strategic thinker and relationship builder, leveraging automation to amplify their impact.

Data-Driven Decision Making ● Empowering Employees with Insights

A significant impact of automation is the generation of vast amounts of data. SMBs that strategically implement automation gain access to real-time insights into their operations, customer behavior, and market trends. This data, however, is only valuable if employees are equipped to interpret and utilize it effectively. Automation, therefore, necessitates a shift towards data-driven decision-making at all levels within the SMB.

Sales teams can use CRM data to personalize customer interactions and optimize sales strategies. Marketing teams can analyze campaign performance data to refine their approaches and maximize ROI. Operations teams can leverage data from automated systems to identify bottlenecks and improve efficiency. This data-driven approach empowers employees to make more informed decisions, contributing to improved business outcomes and fostering a culture of continuous improvement.

Strategic automation empowers SMB employees with data-driven insights, fostering informed decision-making and continuous improvement.

The Rise of Hybrid Roles ● Blending Human and Machine Capabilities

Automation is fostering the emergence of hybrid roles within SMBs, roles that blend human skills with the capabilities of automated systems. Consider a customer service representative in a small e-commerce business. Automation, through chatbots and AI-powered support tools, can handle basic inquiries and resolve common issues. However, the human representative steps in for complex problems, personalized assistance, and situations requiring empathy and emotional intelligence.

This hybrid role leverages automation for efficiency while retaining the essential human touch for customer satisfaction. Similarly, in finance, automation can handle routine bookkeeping and financial reporting, while human financial analysts focus on strategic financial planning and risk management. These hybrid roles represent a synergistic approach, maximizing the strengths of both humans and machines.

Strategic Implementation ● Aligning Automation with Business Goals

Successful automation implementation in SMBs requires a strategic approach that aligns automation initiatives with overall business goals. Automation should not be viewed as a standalone project but rather as an integral part of the SMB’s strategic roadmap. This involves a thorough assessment of business processes, identification of areas where automation can deliver the greatest impact, and careful selection of automation tools that align with specific business needs and budget constraints. A piecemeal approach to automation, without a clear strategic vision, can lead to inefficiencies and missed opportunities.

For example, automating marketing without integrating it with sales and customer service automation can create silos and hinder overall business performance. A holistic, strategic approach ensures that automation investments deliver maximum value and contribute to the SMB’s long-term success.

Developing a Future-Ready Workforce ● Reskilling and Upskilling Strategies

As automation reshapes employee roles, SMBs must prioritize reskilling and upskilling initiatives to develop a future-ready workforce. This involves identifying the skills that will be in demand in an increasingly automated environment and providing employees with opportunities to acquire these skills. This might include training in data analysis, digital marketing, cloud computing, cybersecurity, or even areas like emotional intelligence Meaning ● Emotional Intelligence in SMBs: Organizational capacity to leverage emotions for resilience, innovation, and ethical growth. and complex problem-solving, which become even more critical as routine tasks are automated.

SMBs can leverage online learning platforms, industry certifications, and partnerships with local educational institutions to provide cost-effective reskilling and upskilling programs. Investing in employee development Meaning ● Employee Development, in the context of Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), represents a structured investment in the skills, knowledge, and abilities of personnel to bolster organizational performance and individual career paths. not only ensures a smooth transition to an automated environment but also enhances employee engagement, retention, and overall business competitiveness.

Addressing the Skills Gap ● Recruitment and Talent Acquisition in the Age of Automation

The shift towards automation also impacts SMB recruitment and talent acquisition strategies. As roles evolve to require more strategic and technical skills, SMBs may face a skills gap in the labor market. To address this, SMBs need to adapt their recruitment strategies to attract candidates with the skills needed to thrive in an automated environment. This might involve focusing on candidates with data analysis Meaning ● Data analysis, in the context of Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), represents a critical business process of inspecting, cleansing, transforming, and modeling data with the goal of discovering useful information, informing conclusions, and supporting strategic decision-making. skills, digital literacy, and adaptability.

SMBs can also explore alternative talent pools, such as freelancers and remote workers, who may possess specialized skills in automation-related areas. Furthermore, SMBs can partner with universities and vocational schools to develop internship and apprenticeship programs that provide students with hands-on experience in automation technologies, creating a pipeline of future talent.

Measuring the Impact ● Key Performance Indicators for Automation Success

To effectively manage and optimize automation initiatives, SMBs need to establish key performance indicators Meaning ● Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) represent measurable values that demonstrate how effectively a small or medium-sized business (SMB) is achieving key business objectives. (KPIs) to measure the impact of automation on employee roles and overall business performance. These KPIs should go beyond simple metrics like cost reduction and efficiency gains. They should also encompass employee-centric metrics such as employee satisfaction, skill development, and role enrichment. For example, KPIs could include:

Regularly monitoring these KPIs allows SMBs to assess the effectiveness of their automation strategies, identify areas for improvement, and ensure that automation is delivering tangible benefits for both the business and its employees.

Ethical Considerations ● Navigating the Human-Automation Partnership Responsibly

As SMBs increasingly integrate automation into their operations, ethical considerations become paramount. Responsible automation implementation Meaning ● Ethical and strategic tech deployment in SMBs for sustainable growth and positive impact. requires SMBs to consider the potential impact on employees, customers, and the broader community. This includes ensuring fairness and transparency in automation decisions, protecting employee privacy and data security, and mitigating potential biases in AI-powered automation systems.

SMBs should proactively address ethical concerns by establishing clear guidelines for automation implementation, engaging in open dialogue with employees about automation plans, and prioritizing ethical considerations in the selection and deployment of automation technologies. A responsible approach to automation builds trust, fosters a positive work environment, and ensures that automation benefits all stakeholders.

Competitive Advantage ● Automation as a Strategic Differentiator for SMBs

In today’s competitive landscape, automation is no longer a luxury for SMBs; it’s a strategic differentiator. SMBs that strategically embrace automation gain a significant competitive advantage over those that lag behind. Automation enables SMBs to operate more efficiently, offer better products and services, and respond more quickly to changing market demands. It allows them to compete with larger corporations on a more level playing field, leveraging technology to overcome resource constraints.

For example, a small online retailer that automates its order fulfillment process can offer faster shipping and more efficient customer service than larger competitors with less agile operations. Automation empowers SMBs to innovate, scale, and thrive in an increasingly competitive global marketplace. The extent to which SMBs embrace and strategically implement automation will significantly determine their future success and sustainability.

Strategic automation is not just about efficiency; it’s a competitive differentiator empowering SMBs to innovate, scale, and thrive in a dynamic market.

Embracing Complexity ● The Nuanced Impact of Automation on SMB Roles

The impact of automation on SMB employee roles is complex and nuanced. It’s not a simple story of job replacement or technological disruption. It’s a story of transformation, evolution, and opportunity. Strategic automation, when implemented thoughtfully and ethically, has the potential to enhance employee roles, empower SMBs, and drive sustainable growth.

Navigating this complex landscape requires SMB leaders to embrace a strategic mindset, invest in employee development, and prioritize ethical considerations. The SMBs that successfully navigate this transition will be well-positioned to thrive in the age of automation, leveraging technology to unlock human potential and achieve new levels of success.

Reconceptualizing Smb Employee Roles Through Algorithmic Integration

Contemporary business analytics reveal a stark reality ● SMBs adopting advanced automation, including AI-driven systems, experience a 40% increase in operational efficiency within the first year, according to a 2024 industry report by Gartner. This statistic, however, obscures a more profound transformation ● a reconceptualization of SMB employee roles driven by algorithmic integration. The impact of automation transcends mere task substitution; it necessitates a fundamental rethinking of organizational structures, skill sets, and the very nature of work within SMBs. This advanced perspective demands a critical examination of how automation, particularly sophisticated algorithmic systems, reshapes the human-machine dynamic in the SMB context.

Algorithmic Disruption ● Beyond Repetitive Tasks to Cognitive Functions

Advanced automation, characterized by algorithmic systems and artificial intelligence, extends its reach beyond routine, repetitive tasks into areas previously considered exclusively human domains ● cognitive functions. AI-powered tools can now perform tasks such as data analysis, market forecasting, content creation, and even aspects of decision-making. This algorithmic disruption challenges traditional notions of employee roles, particularly in knowledge-based SMB sectors.

For example, in a small financial services firm, AI algorithms can analyze market data, identify investment opportunities, and generate client reports, tasks traditionally performed by human financial analysts. This doesn’t necessarily eliminate the need for analysts, but it fundamentally alters their role, shifting the focus from data crunching and report generation to strategic interpretation, client relationship management, and ethical oversight of algorithmic recommendations.

The Augmented Workforce ● Human-Algorithm Collaboration and Synergy

The advanced stage of automation impact is characterized by the emergence of the augmented workforce ● a synergistic collaboration between human employees and algorithmic systems. This model moves beyond simple task automation to create a dynamic partnership where humans and machines leverage their respective strengths. Algorithms excel at processing vast amounts of data, identifying patterns, and performing repetitive tasks with speed and accuracy. Humans bring to the table creativity, critical thinking, emotional intelligence, ethical judgment, and the ability to handle complex, ambiguous situations.

In an augmented workforce, algorithms empower employees by providing them with data-driven insights, automating routine tasks, and freeing up their time for higher-level activities. Human employees, in turn, oversee algorithmic systems, interpret their outputs, make strategic decisions, and provide the essential human touch in customer interactions and complex problem-solving. This human-algorithm synergy creates a more productive, innovative, and resilient SMB workforce.

Algorithmic integration fosters an augmented workforce model, creating a synergistic partnership between human employees and AI systems.

Organizational Restructuring ● Flattening Hierarchies and Empowering Frontline Employees

The integration of advanced automation Meaning ● Advanced Automation, in the context of Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), signifies the strategic implementation of sophisticated technologies that move beyond basic task automation to drive significant improvements in business processes, operational efficiency, and scalability. necessitates organizational restructuring within SMBs. Traditional hierarchical structures, often characterized by layers of management overseeing routine tasks, become less relevant in an environment where algorithms handle many of these tasks. Automation facilitates flatter organizational structures, empowering frontline employees with greater autonomy and decision-making authority. With algorithms handling routine data analysis and reporting, middle management roles focused on task supervision may evolve or become redundant.

Frontline employees, equipped with data-driven insights Meaning ● Leveraging factual business information to guide SMB decisions for growth and efficiency. from algorithmic systems, can make more informed decisions, respond more quickly to customer needs, and contribute more directly to strategic initiatives. This organizational flattening fosters agility, innovation, and a more engaged and empowered workforce within SMBs.

Skill Set Evolution ● Emphasis on Algorithmic Literacy and Human-Centric Skills

The demand for specific skill sets within SMBs undergoes a significant evolution in the age of advanced automation. While technical skills related to automation implementation and management become increasingly important, the emphasis shifts towards algorithmic literacy Meaning ● Algorithmic Literacy for SMBs: Understanding & strategically using algorithms for growth, automation, and ethical business practices. and human-centric skills. Algorithmic literacy encompasses the ability to understand how algorithms work, interpret their outputs, and critically evaluate their recommendations. This skill is crucial for employees at all levels within SMBs, enabling them to effectively collaborate with algorithmic systems and make informed decisions based on algorithmic insights.

Simultaneously, human-centric skills such as creativity, critical thinking, emotional intelligence, communication, and collaboration become even more valuable. These skills differentiate human employees from algorithms and are essential for handling complex problems, building relationships, and driving innovation in an automated environment. SMBs must prioritize the development of both algorithmic literacy and human-centric skills within their workforce to thrive in the age of advanced automation.

Ethical Algorithmic Governance ● Ensuring Fairness, Transparency, and Accountability

The increasing reliance on algorithmic systems in SMB operations necessitates robust ethical algorithmic governance Meaning ● Automated rule-based systems guiding SMB operations for efficiency and data-driven decisions. frameworks. Algorithms, while powerful, are not inherently neutral or objective. They can reflect biases present in the data they are trained on or in their design. Ethical algorithmic governance Meaning ● Ethical Algorithmic Governance, within the realm of small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), concerns the frameworks and processes established to ensure fairness, transparency, and accountability in the deployment of algorithms for automation and growth initiatives. ensures that algorithmic systems are used fairly, transparently, and accountably within SMBs.

This includes addressing potential biases in algorithms, protecting employee and customer data privacy, ensuring transparency in algorithmic decision-making processes, and establishing mechanisms for human oversight and intervention when necessary. SMBs must develop and implement ethical algorithmic governance policies and practices to mitigate risks, build trust with employees and customers, and ensure responsible automation implementation. This ethical dimension is crucial for the long-term sustainability and societal acceptance of algorithmic integration in SMBs.

Strategic Algorithmic Advantage ● Innovation, Agility, and Market Differentiation

For SMBs, advanced automation and algorithmic integration represent a strategic imperative for achieving innovation, agility, and market differentiation. Algorithms empower SMBs to analyze vast datasets, identify emerging market trends, personalize customer experiences, and optimize business processes with unprecedented speed and precision. This algorithmic advantage enables SMBs to innovate more rapidly, adapt more quickly to changing market conditions, and differentiate themselves from competitors. For example, a small e-commerce startup can leverage AI algorithms to personalize product recommendations, optimize pricing strategies in real-time, and provide highly targeted marketing campaigns, allowing them to compete effectively with larger, more established players.

Strategic algorithmic integration is not just about efficiency gains; it’s about creating a fundamentally more agile, innovative, and competitive SMB capable of thriving in the dynamic digital economy. The extent to which SMBs strategically cultivate and leverage algorithmic advantage will be a key determinant of their long-term success and market leadership.

Strategic algorithmic integration is paramount for SMBs seeking innovation, agility, and sustainable market differentiation in the digital age.

The Future of Smb Work ● Algorithmic Orchestration and Human Flourishing

The ultimate impact of advanced automation on SMB employee roles points towards a future of work Meaning ● Evolving work landscape for SMBs, driven by tech, demanding strategic adaptation for growth. characterized by algorithmic orchestration Meaning ● Algorithmic Orchestration, for Small and Medium-sized Businesses, describes the automated alignment and synchronization of various software systems and business processes to achieve specific, strategic business outcomes, streamlining operations and maximizing efficiency. and human flourishing. In this future, algorithms will orchestrate many routine business processes, optimizing workflows, allocating resources, and providing data-driven insights. This algorithmic orchestration frees human employees to focus on higher-level, more fulfilling activities that leverage their uniquely human capabilities. Employees can dedicate more time to creative problem-solving, strategic thinking, innovation, relationship building, and personal development.

The focus shifts from task execution to value creation, intellectual stimulation, and personal growth. This future of work, enabled by advanced automation, has the potential to create a more engaging, rewarding, and human-centric work environment within SMBs, fostering both business success and employee flourishing. Realizing this potential requires a proactive and strategic approach to automation implementation, prioritizing ethical considerations, employee development, and a fundamental reconceptualization of SMB employee roles in the algorithmic age.

References

• Brynjolfsson, Erik, and Andrew McAfee. Race Against the Machine ● How the Digital Revolution is Accelerating Innovation, Driving Productivity, and Irreversibly Transforming Employment and the Economy. Digital Frontier Press, 2011.
• Manyika, James, et al. A Future That Works ● Automation, Employment, and Productivity. McKinsey Global Institute, 2017.
• Autor, David H., David Dorn, and Gordon H. Hanson. “The China Syndrome ● Local Labor Market Effects of Import Competition in the United States.” American Economic Review, vol. 103, no. 3, 2013, pp. 2121-68.