Fundamentals

Consider this ● a local bakery, beloved for its sourdough, suddenly finds itself struggling to attract younger customers. They’ve got the best bread in town, according to the old guard, but the foot traffic is dwindling. Now, imagine they decide to hire a young, energetic marketing intern from the community college, someone who is deeply connected to local social media trends and understands the language of TikTok and Instagram. This intern, perhaps from a different ethnic background than the established staff, suggests a social media campaign showcasing not just the bread, but the bakery’s history, the bakers’ stories, and even behind-the-scenes glimpses of the early morning dough-making process.

Suddenly, the bakery’s Instagram feed is alive with vibrant photos and short videos. Local food bloggers, drawn in by the fresh content, start featuring the bakery. Younger customers, who never considered sourdough before, are now lining up, enticed by the bakery’s newfound digital presence and the authentic stories being told. This isn’t some abstract corporate theory; it’s the real-world potential of diversity Meaning ● Diversity in SMBs means strategically leveraging varied perspectives for innovation and ethical growth. initiatives, even in the most unassuming of small businesses. It’s about tapping into perspectives and skill sets that might be overlooked in homogenous environments, and how that injection of varied thinking can directly translate into tangible business outcomes.

Unpacking Diversity in the SMB Context

Diversity, within the context of Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), frequently gets relegated to a human resources checkbox, a matter of compliance rather than strategic advantage. This perspective, however, misses a critical point. For SMBs, often operating on tight margins and intensely reliant on community goodwill, diversity initiatives Meaning ● Diversity initiatives for SMBs strategically foster inclusivity and diverse talent, optimizing resources for business growth and resilience. are not merely about adhering to societal norms; they represent a potent, often untapped, resource for enhanced profitability. Think of diversity not as a quota to be met, but as a spectrum of experiences, backgrounds, and viewpoints that, when effectively harnessed, can supercharge innovation, broaden market reach, and deepen customer engagement.

This encompasses more than just race or gender; it includes age, socioeconomic background, education, sexual orientation, disability, and even neurodiversity. Each of these dimensions brings unique lenses through which to view business challenges and opportunities.

The Bottom Line ● Profitability and Diversity

The question then becomes ● how exactly does this translate to the bottom line for an SMB? The connection might not always be immediately obvious, especially when SMB owners are grappling with day-to-day operational pressures like cash flow, inventory management, and customer service. Yet, the impact of diversity initiatives on long-term profitability is surprisingly direct and multifaceted. Consider customer acquisition.

A diverse workforce is inherently better equipped to understand and cater to a diverse customer base. If your team mirrors the demographics of your target market, they are more likely to anticipate customer needs, tailor products and services effectively, and craft marketing messages that resonate authentically. This isn’t about tokenism; it’s about genuine representation leading to genuine connection and increased sales. Beyond customer acquisition, diversity fuels innovation.

Teams composed of individuals from varied backgrounds bring a wider range of problem-solving approaches and creative ideas to the table. This is particularly crucial for SMBs Meaning ● SMBs are dynamic businesses, vital to economies, characterized by agility, customer focus, and innovation. that need to differentiate themselves in competitive markets. A homogenous team might fall into groupthink, recycling familiar solutions. A diverse team, however, is more likely to challenge assumptions, explore unconventional paths, and develop truly groundbreaking products or services that capture market attention.

Initial Steps ● Implementing Diversity Initiatives in SMBs

For an SMB owner just starting to consider diversity initiatives, the prospect can seem daunting. Where do you even begin? The key is to start small and focus on creating a genuinely inclusive environment, rather than rushing into superficial changes. Begin by examining your current hiring practices.

Are you relying solely on word-of-mouth referrals, which tend to perpetuate existing homogeneity? Explore diversifying your recruitment channels. Post job openings on platforms that specifically target diverse talent pools. Reach out to local community organizations and educational institutions that serve underrepresented groups.

Next, look at your internal culture. Is your workplace welcoming and supportive of individuals from different backgrounds? This isn’t about grand gestures; it’s about creating a culture of respect and open communication. Implement simple measures like diversity and inclusion Meaning ● Diversity & Inclusion for SMBs: Strategic imperative for agility, innovation, and long-term resilience in a diverse world. training for all employees, and establish clear channels for reporting discrimination or bias.

Remember, authenticity is paramount. Employees and customers alike can quickly detect performative diversity initiatives that lack genuine commitment. Focus on building a foundation of inclusivity, and the business benefits will naturally follow.

Diversity initiatives, when viewed as strategic business tools rather than compliance exercises, offer SMBs a pathway to enhanced profitability through innovation, broader market reach, and deeper customer engagement.

Automation and Diversity ● A Synergistic Relationship

Automation, often perceived as a threat to human jobs, can actually be a powerful enabler of diversity initiatives within SMBs. By automating routine tasks, businesses can free up human capital to focus on roles that require creativity, empathy, and complex problem-solving ● areas where diverse perspectives are particularly valuable. Consider customer service. Implementing AI-powered chatbots to handle basic inquiries can allow human customer service representatives to focus on resolving more intricate issues, building rapport with customers, and providing personalized support.

This shift in focus can create opportunities for individuals with strong interpersonal skills, regardless of their background or traditional qualifications. Similarly, in areas like data analysis and marketing, automation Meaning ● Automation for SMBs: Strategically using technology to streamline tasks, boost efficiency, and drive growth. tools can handle data collection and reporting, allowing diverse teams to concentrate on interpreting insights, developing creative strategies, and tailoring campaigns to specific customer segments. Automation can also help mitigate unconscious bias Meaning ● Unconscious biases are ingrained social stereotypes SMB owners and employees unknowingly harbor, influencing decisions related to hiring, promotions, and project assignments, often hindering diversity and innovation within a growing company. in hiring and promotion processes. AI-powered recruitment tools, for example, can be programmed to screen resumes based on skills and qualifications, rather than demographic factors.

This can help level the playing field and ensure that diverse candidates are given fair consideration. The synergy between automation and diversity initiatives lies in the fact that automation can handle repetitive tasks, freeing up human talent to leverage their unique perspectives and skills, ultimately driving innovation and profitability for SMBs.

Implementation Challenges and Practical Solutions

Implementing diversity initiatives in SMBs is not without its challenges. Limited resources, time constraints, and ingrained biases can all present obstacles. However, these challenges are not insurmountable. One common hurdle is the perception that diversity initiatives are costly and time-consuming.

While comprehensive programs may require investment, many impactful steps can be taken with minimal resources. For example, partnering with local diversity organizations can provide access to diverse talent pools and resources at low or no cost. Utilizing free online diversity and inclusion training materials can educate employees without significant financial outlay. Another challenge is overcoming unconscious bias.

Everyone has biases, and these can inadvertently influence hiring decisions and workplace interactions. Raising awareness of unconscious bias through training and open discussions is a crucial first step. Implementing structured interview processes, using standardized evaluation criteria, and involving diverse interview panels can further mitigate bias in hiring. Resistance to change is another potential obstacle.

Some employees may be uncomfortable with diversity initiatives, fearing that they will lead to reverse discrimination or disrupt existing workplace dynamics. Addressing these concerns openly and transparently is essential. Clearly communicate the business rationale for diversity initiatives, emphasizing the benefits for all employees and the long-term success of the company. Highlighting success stories and demonstrating tangible positive outcomes can help build buy-in and overcome resistance. The key to successful implementation Meaning ● Implementation in SMBs is the dynamic process of turning strategic plans into action, crucial for growth and requiring adaptability and strategic alignment. is a phased approach, starting with small, manageable steps, focusing on creating a genuinely inclusive culture, and consistently communicating the value of diversity to the entire organization.

Intermediate

The narrative that diversity is simply “the right thing to do” often falls flat in the pragmatic world of SMB operations, where every decision is weighed against its impact on the balance sheet. While ethical considerations are undeniably important, framing diversity initiatives solely through a moral lens overlooks their powerful strategic value. Consider the example of a mid-sized manufacturing company specializing in custom metal fabrication. For years, their engineering and design teams were predominantly composed of individuals with similar educational backgrounds and professional experiences.

They were proficient, yes, but their innovation pipeline had stagnated. Then, the company made a conscious effort to recruit engineers and designers from diverse backgrounds ● individuals with experience in different industries, international perspectives, and unconventional skill sets. The result was a surge in creative problem-solving. One team, grappling with a complex design challenge for a new aerospace component, benefited immensely from the insights of an engineer who had previously worked in automotive manufacturing.

Her experience with lightweight materials and efficient production processes, seemingly unrelated to aerospace, provided a breakthrough solution that the homogenous team had overlooked. This isn’t anecdotal happenstance; it’s a demonstration of how cognitive diversity, a direct outcome of diversity initiatives, can unlock innovation and drive tangible improvements in operational efficiency and product development, directly impacting profitability.

Beyond Representation ● Cognitive Diversity and Innovation

Moving beyond the fundamental understanding of diversity as mere representation, the intermediate level of analysis delves into the concept of cognitive diversity. This refers to the variations in thought processes, perspectives, and problem-solving approaches within a team or organization. Research consistently demonstrates that cognitively diverse teams are more innovative, make better decisions, and are more resilient in the face of complex challenges. For SMBs, operating in dynamic and often unpredictable markets, this innovative edge is not a luxury; it’s a necessity for long-term survival and growth.

Cognitive diversity arises from a multitude of factors, including demographic diversity (race, gender, ethnicity), but also functional diversity (varied professional backgrounds, industry experience), and even personality diversity (different communication styles, risk tolerances). The key is to create an environment where these diverse cognitive perspectives are not just present, but actively encouraged and integrated into decision-making processes. This requires more than simply hiring diverse individuals; it demands a conscious effort to foster inclusive leadership, promote psychological safety, and establish communication norms that value diverse viewpoints, even when they challenge conventional wisdom.

Market Expansion and Customer Segmentation through Diversity

SMBs often seek to expand their market reach to fuel growth. Diversity initiatives can be a powerful catalyst in this endeavor. A diverse workforce possesses an inherent understanding of diverse customer segments, enabling SMBs to penetrate new markets and tailor their offerings more effectively. Consider a regional chain of coffee shops aiming to expand into a new, more diverse urban area.

Their existing marketing strategies, developed by a homogenous team, might rely on assumptions about customer preferences that are not universally applicable. However, by incorporating diverse perspectives into their marketing and product development teams, they can gain valuable insights into the nuances of the new market. This might involve adapting their menu to include culturally relevant beverage options, designing marketing campaigns that resonate with specific ethnic communities, or even modifying store layouts to create a more welcoming atmosphere for diverse customer groups. This targeted approach, informed by diverse internal perspectives, is far more effective than a generic, one-size-fits-all strategy.

Diversity also enhances customer service. Customers are more likely to feel understood and valued when they interact with employees who reflect their own backgrounds and experiences. This fosters trust, loyalty, and positive word-of-mouth referrals, all crucial drivers of SMB profitability. In essence, diversity initiatives are not just about internal representation; they are about building a bridge to diverse customer markets and unlocking untapped revenue streams.

Risk Mitigation and Enhanced Decision-Making

SMBs operate in a world of inherent risks, from market fluctuations to supply chain disruptions. Diversity initiatives can contribute to risk mitigation by enhancing decision-making processes. Homogenous teams, prone to groupthink and confirmation bias, may overlook potential risks or make rash decisions based on limited perspectives. Diverse teams, on the other hand, are more likely to challenge assumptions, consider alternative scenarios, and identify potential blind spots.

This leads to more robust and well-informed decision-making, reducing the likelihood of costly errors and enhancing organizational resilience. Consider a small tech startup developing a new software platform. A homogenous team of developers might focus solely on the technical aspects of the product, neglecting crucial considerations such as user accessibility, ethical implications, or potential security vulnerabilities. A diverse team, including individuals with backgrounds in ethics, user experience, and cybersecurity, is more likely to identify and address these potential risks early in the development process, preventing costly rework or reputational damage down the line.

Diversity in decision-making is not about slowing things down with endless debates; it’s about ensuring that decisions are made with a broader understanding of potential consequences and a more comprehensive assessment of risks and opportunities. This proactive risk management contributes directly to long-term profitability and sustainability for SMBs.

Cognitive diversity, fostered through strategic diversity initiatives, is a potent driver of innovation, market expansion, and risk mitigation, directly impacting the long-term profitability and resilience of SMBs.

Automation for Scaling Diversity and Inclusion

Automation, at the intermediate level, moves beyond simply streamlining tasks; it becomes a strategic tool for scaling diversity and inclusion initiatives across the SMB. Consider employee training. Developing and delivering comprehensive diversity and inclusion training programs for every employee in a growing SMB can be resource-intensive and logistically challenging. However, leveraging e-learning platforms and automated training modules can make this process scalable and cost-effective.

These platforms can track employee progress, provide personalized learning paths, and ensure consistent delivery of training content across the organization, regardless of location or team size. Automation can also enhance data collection and analysis related to diversity metrics. Manually tracking diversity data across various departments and functions can be cumbersome and prone to errors. Implementing HR analytics software can automate this process, providing real-time dashboards and reports on key diversity indicators.

This data-driven approach allows SMBs to monitor the effectiveness of their diversity initiatives, identify areas for improvement, and make informed decisions based on concrete evidence, rather than anecdotal observations. Furthermore, automation can facilitate inclusive communication and collaboration. Tools like AI-powered translation services can break down language barriers within diverse teams, enabling seamless communication and knowledge sharing. Project management platforms with built-in accessibility features can ensure that all team members, regardless of disability, can participate fully in collaborative projects. Automation, therefore, is not just about efficiency; it’s about creating scalable and sustainable infrastructure for diversity and inclusion, embedding these principles into the very fabric of the SMB’s operations.

Overcoming Systemic Barriers and Fostering True Inclusion

While initial implementation challenges might revolve around awareness and resource allocation, the intermediate stage of diversity initiatives often confronts more systemic barriers. These are deeply ingrained biases and structural inequalities that can hinder progress even when intentions are good. One such barrier is unconscious bias in performance evaluations and promotion processes. Even with structured evaluation criteria, subtle biases can creep in, leading to disproportionately negative assessments for employees from underrepresented groups.

Mitigating this requires going beyond basic unconscious bias training and implementing more robust strategies, such as blind resume reviews for promotions, 360-degree feedback processes, and mentorship programs specifically designed to support the career advancement of diverse employees. Another systemic barrier is the lack of inclusive leadership. Leaders who are not equipped to manage diverse teams effectively can inadvertently create environments where some employees feel marginalized or excluded. Leadership development programs that focus on inclusive leadership skills, such as cultural competency, empathy, and conflict resolution, are crucial for fostering a truly inclusive workplace.

Furthermore, SMBs need to address issues of pay equity and opportunity parity. Conducting regular pay audits to identify and rectify any gender or racial pay gaps is essential for demonstrating a genuine commitment to fairness. Creating clear pathways for career advancement and ensuring that all employees have equal access to training and development opportunities are also critical for fostering a culture of inclusion. Overcoming systemic barriers requires a long-term commitment, a willingness to challenge the status quo, and a continuous process of learning, adaptation, and improvement. It’s about moving beyond surface-level diversity to create a truly equitable and inclusive organizational culture Meaning ● Organizational culture is the shared personality of an SMB, shaping behavior and impacting success. where all employees can thrive and contribute their full potential.

Advanced

The discourse surrounding diversity initiatives often operates within a relatively narrow band, focusing on immediate benefits like improved public image or enhanced employee morale. This perspective, while valid, fails to capture the truly transformative potential of diversity as a fundamental driver of long-term organizational resilience and competitive advantage in the complex, globalized business landscape. Consider the case of a multinational software corporation, operating across diverse geographical markets and facing constant disruption from emerging technologies. Their leadership recognized that traditional homogenous organizational structures were ill-equipped to navigate this volatile environment.

They embarked on a radical transformation, embedding diversity and inclusion at the core of their corporate strategy, not as a separate initiative, but as an integral component of their innovation engine and risk management framework. This involved not only diversifying their workforce across all levels, but also fundamentally restructuring their decision-making processes to leverage diverse perspectives at every stage, from product development to market entry strategies. The outcome was not merely incremental improvements; it was a profound shift in organizational agility Meaning ● Organizational Agility: SMB's capacity to swiftly adapt & leverage change for growth through flexible processes & strategic automation. and adaptability. They were able to anticipate market shifts more effectively, develop innovative solutions tailored to diverse customer needs, and navigate geopolitical uncertainties with greater resilience. This isn’t just about ticking boxes; it’s about building a fundamentally different kind of organization, one that is inherently more robust, innovative, and future-proof, and where diversity is not simply tolerated, but actively cultivated as a strategic imperative for sustained profitability and long-term success.

Diversity as a Catalyst for Organizational Agility and Adaptability

At the advanced level, diversity initiatives are understood not just as a means to improve internal culture or enhance brand reputation, but as a critical lever for building organizational agility and adaptability ● capabilities that are paramount in today’s rapidly evolving business environment. The ability to adapt quickly to market changes, technological disruptions, and unforeseen global events is no longer a competitive advantage; it is a survival imperative. Diverse organizations, characterized by a wide range of perspectives, experiences, and problem-solving approaches, are inherently more agile and adaptable. They are less susceptible to groupthink, more adept at identifying emerging trends, and more capable of developing innovative solutions to complex challenges.

This agility stems from several interconnected factors. Firstly, diverse teams possess a broader cognitive toolkit, enabling them to approach problems from multiple angles and generate a wider range of potential solutions. Secondly, diverse organizations are better at sensing and responding to changes in diverse customer markets, as their internal workforce mirrors the demographics and preferences of their customer base. Thirdly, diverse organizations are more resilient to external shocks, as their varied perspectives and experiences allow them to anticipate and mitigate risks more effectively.

Building organizational agility through diversity requires a holistic approach that goes beyond surface-level representation. It demands a fundamental shift in organizational culture, leadership practices, and decision-making processes, embedding diversity and inclusion at the core of the organization’s DNA.

Leveraging Diversity for Global Market Penetration and Expansion

For SMBs with aspirations for global expansion, diversity initiatives become an indispensable strategic asset. Navigating international markets requires a deep understanding of diverse cultural norms, consumer preferences, and regulatory landscapes. A homogenous organization, lacking internal diversity, is likely to struggle in this complex environment, making costly missteps and missing crucial market opportunities. Diverse teams, on the other hand, bring invaluable cultural intelligence and global perspectives to the table.

They can provide insights into local market nuances, adapt products and services to meet specific cultural needs, and build trust and rapport with diverse international customers and partners. Consider an SMB in the e-commerce sector seeking to expand into Asian markets. A diverse team, including individuals with Asian cultural backgrounds and language skills, can provide critical guidance on website localization, marketing strategies tailored to specific cultural preferences, and customer service approaches that resonate with local consumers. This cultural competency is not just about avoiding cultural faux pas; it’s about building genuine connections with international markets and unlocking significant growth potential.

Furthermore, diverse teams are better equipped to navigate the complexities of global supply chains and international partnerships. They can leverage their diverse networks to identify reliable suppliers, negotiate favorable deals, and manage cross-cultural collaborations effectively. In essence, diversity initiatives are not just about domestic representation; they are about building the internal capabilities necessary to succeed in the global marketplace and achieve sustainable international growth.

Diversity, Automation, and the Future of Work

The advanced perspective on diversity initiatives must consider the transformative impact of automation and artificial intelligence on the future of work. As automation increasingly takes over routine and repetitive tasks, the demand for uniquely human skills ● creativity, critical thinking, emotional intelligence, and complex problem-solving ● will only intensify. These are precisely the skills that are amplified by diversity. Diverse teams are inherently more creative, as they bring a wider range of perspectives and experiences to bear on problem-solving.

They are also better at critical thinking, as diverse viewpoints challenge assumptions and promote more rigorous analysis. Emotional intelligence, the ability to understand and manage emotions, is crucial for effective collaboration and communication in diverse teams. And complex problem-solving, the ability to tackle ambiguous and multifaceted challenges, is enhanced by the cognitive diversity Meaning ● Cognitive Diversity: Strategic orchestration of varied thinking for SMB growth and innovation. inherent in diverse groups. Automation, therefore, does not diminish the importance of diversity; it actually elevates it.

In a future where routine tasks are automated, human value will be increasingly defined by these uniquely human skills, and diversity will be the key to unlocking and amplifying these skills within organizations. SMBs that proactively embrace diversity and leverage automation strategically will be best positioned to thrive in this future of work. This involves not only diversifying their workforce, but also investing in training and development programs that cultivate these uniquely human skills, and creating organizational cultures that value and reward diversity of thought and experience. The synergy between diversity and automation is not just about efficiency gains; it’s about building a future-proof workforce and organization that is resilient, innovative, and adaptable in the face of rapid technological change.

Diversity initiatives, viewed through an advanced strategic lens, are not merely about social responsibility, but about building fundamental organizational agility, global market competency, and a future-proof workforce in the age of automation.

Implementing Deep Diversity ● Beyond Surface Metrics

Advanced implementation of diversity initiatives moves beyond simply tracking surface-level demographic metrics. While representation is important, true diversity impact requires delving into deeper dimensions of inclusion and equity. This involves measuring and monitoring not just who is in the organization, but also how equitably opportunities are distributed, how inclusive the organizational culture is, and how effectively diverse perspectives are being leveraged in decision-making. Metrics like promotion rates across different demographic groups, employee satisfaction scores disaggregated by diversity dimensions, and representation in leadership positions provide a more nuanced picture of diversity progress than simple headcount figures.

Furthermore, advanced diversity implementation requires addressing systemic inequities that may be embedded in organizational policies and practices. This might involve reviewing compensation structures for pay equity, analyzing performance evaluation processes for unconscious bias, and auditing promotion criteria for fairness and transparency. It also necessitates creating robust mechanisms for employees to report discrimination or bias, and ensuring that these reports are addressed promptly and effectively. Building a truly inclusive culture requires ongoing dialogue, feedback, and adaptation.

Regular employee surveys, focus groups, and diversity councils can provide valuable insights into employee experiences and identify areas for improvement. Leadership accountability is also paramount. Diversity and inclusion goals should be integrated into leadership performance metrics, and leaders should be held accountable for fostering inclusive teams and driving diversity progress. Advanced diversity implementation is not a one-time project; it’s a continuous journey of learning, improvement, and cultural transformation, requiring sustained commitment and a data-driven, systemic approach.

The Controversial Edge ● Challenging Conventional SMB Norms

Adopting a truly advanced approach to diversity initiatives within the SMB landscape can be inherently controversial, particularly when it challenges deeply ingrained conventional norms. The traditional SMB mindset often prioritizes homogeneity, valuing established networks, shared cultural backgrounds, and a “family-like” atmosphere. Diversity initiatives, especially those that actively seek to disrupt existing power structures and challenge ingrained biases, can be perceived as disruptive, unnecessary, or even threatening to this traditional ethos. There might be resistance from employees who are comfortable with the status quo, concerns about potential conflicts arising from diverse viewpoints, or skepticism about the tangible business benefits of diversity, particularly in the short term.

Addressing this controversy requires a bold and transparent communication strategy. SMB leaders need to articulate a clear and compelling business case for diversity, emphasizing the long-term strategic advantages and addressing concerns openly and honestly. This might involve sharing data and research that demonstrates the link between diversity and profitability, highlighting success stories of diverse SMBs, and engaging in open dialogues with employees to address their anxieties and misconceptions. It also requires a willingness to challenge conventional SMB practices, such as relying solely on word-of-mouth recruitment or promoting based on informal networks.

Embracing diversity in a truly transformative way often necessitates a fundamental shift in organizational culture and operating norms, and this shift can be met with resistance. However, SMBs that are willing to navigate this controversy and embrace the challenges of deep diversity implementation are ultimately positioning themselves for long-term success in an increasingly diverse and complex world. The controversial edge of advanced diversity initiatives lies in their power to disrupt the status quo, challenge conventional thinking, and unlock a new level of organizational potential, even when faced with initial resistance and skepticism.

References

• Herring, Cedric. “Does Diversity Pay? ● Race, Gender, and the Business Case for Diversity.” American Sociological Review, vol. 74, no. 2, 2009, pp. 208-230.
• Rock, David, and Heidi Grant. “Why Diverse Teams Are Smarter.” Harvard Business Review, 4 Nov. 2016, hbr.org/2016/11/why-diverse-teams-are-smarter.
• Hunt, Vivian, et al. “Delivering through Diversity.” McKinsey & Company, Jan. 2018, www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/delivering-through-diversity.
• Østergaard, Christian R., et al. “Does a Different Viewpoint Enhance Innovation? ● The Effect of Managerial Diversity on Innovation.” Research Policy, vol. 40, no. 3, 2011, pp. 382-392.
• Hewlett, Sylvia Ann, et al. “How Diversity Can Drive Innovation.” Harvard Business Review, Dec. 2013, hbr.org/2013/12/how-diversity-can-drive-innovation.