Fundamentals

Consider this ● a local bakery, beloved for its sourdough, starts using customer data Meaning ● Customer Data, in the sphere of SMB growth, automation, and implementation, represents the total collection of information pertaining to a business's customers; it is gathered, structured, and leveraged to gain deeper insights into customer behavior, preferences, and needs to inform strategic business decisions. gleaned from online orders to personalize promotions. Initially, sales jump. However, customers soon realize their purchase history of, say, gluten-free options after a diagnosis is being overtly marketed back to them. Trust erodes faster than a meringue in humidity.

This isn’t just about privacy settings; it touches the core of data ethics Meaning ● Data Ethics for SMBs: Strategic integration of moral principles for trust, innovation, and sustainable growth in the data-driven age. and its surprisingly direct impact on a small business’s bottom line. Data ethics, often perceived as a concern only for tech giants, is in reality a crucial, albeit frequently overlooked, ingredient in the recipe for SMB profitability.

Building Trust From Scratch

For small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), trust operates as the foundational bedrock upon which customer relationships, and consequently, profitability, are built. Unlike large corporations that can sometimes weather public relations storms with sheer marketing muscle, SMBs exist within communities. Their reputations are forged in daily interactions, word-of-mouth referrals, and the tangible experiences they provide.

Data ethics enters this picture as a silent partner, either reinforcing or undermining this trust with every piece of customer information handled. When an SMB demonstrates a commitment to ethical data Meaning ● Ethical Data, within the scope of SMB growth, automation, and implementation, centers on the responsible collection, storage, and utilization of data in alignment with legal and moral business principles. practices, it sends a powerful signal ● ‘We value you, not just your data.’ This resonates deeply, fostering loyalty that transcends fleeting discounts or trendy marketing campaigns.

Ethical data handling is not merely a cost center for SMBs; it’s a strategic investment in long-term customer loyalty and brand reputation.

Think of the local bookstore that remembers your preferred authors and subtly suggests new releases, versus the online retailer that bombards you with generic ads after a single browsing session. The former feels like a personalized service, an extension of the community feel SMBs often cultivate. The latter? It can feel intrusive, a violation of the implicit trust placed in the business.

This distinction is critical. Ethical data practices Meaning ● Ethical Data Practices: Responsible and respectful data handling for SMB growth and trust. are about respecting customer autonomy and privacy, even when the data itself could be used to squeeze out a few extra percentage points of immediate profit. The long game for SMBs involves building lasting relationships, and data ethics is a cornerstone of that strategy.

Transparency ● The Open Door Policy of Data

Transparency in data handling for SMBs translates to an open door policy regarding customer information. It means clearly communicating what data is collected, why it’s collected, and how it’s used ● all in plain, understandable language, not buried in legalese. For an SMB, this might involve a simple notice at the point of data collection, whether it’s an online form or an in-store sign-up sheet. It’s about informing customers, not just complying with regulations.

This upfront honesty can preemptively address customer concerns and build confidence. Consider the difference between a website that vaguely mentions data collection in a lengthy privacy policy versus one that explicitly states, “We collect your email to send you occasional updates about our new products and special offers. We will never share your information with third parties.” The latter approach is direct, reassuring, and embodies transparency.

Furthermore, transparency extends to giving customers control over their data. SMBs can implement straightforward mechanisms for customers to access, modify, or delete their data. This could be as simple as including an ‘unsubscribe’ link in every marketing email or providing a contact email for data inquiries. Empowering customers in this way is not just ethically sound; it’s strategically advantageous.

It reduces the likelihood of customer complaints, builds positive word-of-mouth, and demonstrates a genuine commitment to customer-centric values. In an era of increasing data awareness, this level of transparency can become a significant differentiator for SMBs, setting them apart from less scrupulous competitors.

Data Minimization ● Less Is Truly More

Data minimization, a core tenet of data ethics, advocates for collecting only the data that is strictly necessary for a specific purpose. For SMBs, this principle translates to a leaner, more efficient, and ethically sound data strategy. It’s tempting to gather as much customer data as possible, driven by the allure of comprehensive profiles and highly targeted marketing. However, for most SMBs, this approach is not only ethically questionable but also practically inefficient.

Storing and processing vast amounts of data incurs costs, increases security risks, and can lead to analysis paralysis. Data minimization Meaning ● Strategic data reduction for SMB agility, security, and customer trust, minimizing collection to only essential data. offers a smarter alternative ● focus on collecting only what you genuinely need to serve your customers better.

For instance, a local coffee shop with a loyalty program might only need to track purchase frequency and preferred drink types to personalize rewards effectively. They likely don’t need to know customers’ ages, addresses, or browsing history on other websites. By limiting data collection to these essential data points, the coffee shop reduces its data storage burden, simplifies its analytics, and minimizes the potential for privacy breaches. This focused approach aligns with ethical principles and makes good business sense.

It demonstrates respect for customer privacy while still enabling effective personalization and targeted marketing. In essence, data minimization is about working smarter, not harder, with customer data, maximizing impact while minimizing ethical and operational risks.

Fairness and Algorithmic Awareness

Fairness in data ethics, particularly in the context of algorithms, is about ensuring that automated decision-making processes do not unfairly discriminate against certain customer groups. While SMBs may not be deploying complex AI algorithms, they increasingly use data-driven tools for tasks like targeted advertising, credit scoring for payment plans, or even automated customer service chatbots. It’s crucial to be aware of the potential for bias in these tools and the data they rely on.

Algorithms are trained on data, and if that data reflects existing societal biases, the algorithm can perpetuate and even amplify those biases. For SMBs, this can lead to unfair or discriminatory outcomes, damaging both reputation and profitability.

Consider an online boutique using an algorithm to target ads for luxury items. If the algorithm is trained on historical data that over-represents certain demographics, it might inadvertently exclude potential customers from other groups who could also be interested. This isn’t just ethically problematic; it’s a missed business opportunity. SMBs need to critically evaluate the algorithms they use, understand the data they are trained on, and monitor for unintended biases.

This might involve testing different algorithms, diversifying data sources, and regularly auditing automated decision-making processes. By actively promoting fairness in their data practices, SMBs can not only uphold ethical standards but also expand their customer base and ensure equitable access to their products and services.

Security as a Profit Protector

Data security, often viewed as a purely technical concern, is fundamentally a matter of business ethics and, crucially, profitability for SMBs. In today’s digital landscape, data breaches are not just abstract threats; they are real and present dangers that can cripple a small business. The cost of a data breach extends far beyond immediate financial losses from fines or remediation. It encompasses reputational damage, loss of customer trust, and potential legal liabilities.

For an SMB, these consequences can be devastating, potentially leading to closure. Investing in robust data security Meaning ● Data Security, in the context of SMB growth, automation, and implementation, represents the policies, practices, and technologies deployed to safeguard digital assets from unauthorized access, use, disclosure, disruption, modification, or destruction. measures is therefore not merely a compliance exercise; it’s a proactive strategy to protect profitability and ensure business continuity.

SMBs can implement practical security measures without breaking the bank. This includes basic cyber hygiene practices like strong passwords, regular software updates, and employee training on phishing awareness. Utilizing secure cloud storage solutions, implementing encryption for sensitive data, and having a clear data breach response plan are also essential steps. Furthermore, SMBs can communicate their security measures to customers, reassuring them that their data is protected.

This transparency can be a competitive advantage, particularly in sectors where data privacy Meaning ● Data privacy for SMBs is the responsible handling of personal data to build trust and enable sustainable business growth. is a significant concern. By prioritizing data security, SMBs not only mitigate risks but also build customer confidence and safeguard their long-term financial health. Data security, therefore, functions as a vital profit protector in the ethically conscious SMB landscape.

SMBs stand at a unique crossroads. Embracing data ethics is not a hurdle, but a highway to sustained profitability.

Strategic Data Stewardship For Smb Competitive Advantage

The narrative that data ethics is solely a concern for sprawling multinational corporations overlooks a critical reality ● ethical data practices can be a potent differentiator for small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs), carving out a competitive edge in increasingly data-saturated markets. While large enterprises grapple with complex regulatory landscapes and public scrutiny, SMBs possess an agility and direct customer connection that allows them to operationalize data ethics in ways that genuinely resonate with their customer base, translating into tangible profitability gains. This is not about mere compliance; it’s about strategic data Meaning ● Strategic Data, for Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs), refers to the carefully selected and managed data assets that directly inform key strategic decisions related to growth, automation, and efficient implementation of business initiatives. stewardship.

Ethical Data as a Brand Differentiator

In markets saturated with similar products and services, brand differentiation becomes paramount. SMBs, often lacking the marketing budgets of larger competitors, must find alternative avenues to stand out. Ethical data practices offer a compelling and increasingly valued point of differentiation. Consumers are growing more discerning about how their data is handled, and they are actively seeking out businesses that align with their values.

An SMB that genuinely prioritizes data ethics can cultivate a brand image of trustworthiness and integrity, attracting and retaining customers who prioritize these values. This is particularly relevant in sectors where customer trust is inherently high, such as healthcare, education, or financial services, but its influence extends across all industries.

Consider two online retailers selling similar handcrafted goods. One vaguely references data privacy in its terms of service, while the other prominently displays a ‘Data Ethics Charter’ outlining its commitment to transparency, data minimization, and customer control. The latter SMB is not only demonstrating ethical responsibility but also actively marketing its values. This can resonate strongly with ethically conscious consumers, who may be willing to pay a premium or show greater loyalty to a brand that reflects their own principles.

Ethical data practices, therefore, move beyond being a cost of doing business; they become a strategic marketing asset, enhancing brand perception and driving customer preference. For SMBs, this translates directly into a stronger brand and increased profitability.

Customer Lifetime Value Amplification

Customer Lifetime Value (CLTV), a crucial metric for SMB sustainability, is significantly amplified by ethical data practices. Building long-term customer relationships Meaning ● Customer Relationships, within the framework of SMB expansion, automation processes, and strategic execution, defines the methodologies and technologies SMBs use to manage and analyze customer interactions throughout the customer lifecycle. hinges on trust and loyalty. When customers feel respected and valued, particularly concerning their personal data, they are more likely to remain loyal, make repeat purchases, and advocate for the brand. Conversely, data breaches or unethical data handling can irrevocably damage customer relationships, leading to churn and negative word-of-mouth.

Ethical data practices act as a powerful loyalty engine, fostering customer retention and maximizing CLTV. This is far more cost-effective than constantly acquiring new customers to replace those lost due to data privacy concerns.

Ethical data practices are not a constraint on profitability; they are a catalyst for sustainable growth and enhanced customer lifetime value.

Imagine a subscription box service that ethically handles customer data. It transparently communicates its data practices, provides easy opt-out options, and uses data solely to personalize the subscription experience. Customers are more likely to trust this service, remain subscribed for longer periods, and even upgrade to premium tiers. Now contrast this with a service that aggressively mines customer data, bombards them with irrelevant ads, and makes it difficult to manage privacy settings.

Customers may quickly become disillusioned, cancel their subscriptions, and share their negative experiences. The ethical service, by prioritizing data respect, cultivates a loyal customer base with a higher CLTV, directly contributing to long-term profitability. For SMBs, focusing on ethical data practices is a strategic investment in maximizing the value of each customer relationship.

Operational Efficiency Through Data Ethics

Counterintuitively, ethical data practices can drive operational efficiency Meaning ● Maximizing SMB output with minimal, ethical input for sustainable growth and future readiness. within SMBs. Data minimization, a core ethical principle, inherently streamlines data management. By collecting only necessary data, SMBs reduce storage costs, simplify data processing, and minimize the risk of data breaches. Furthermore, transparent data practices can reduce customer service inquiries related to data privacy, freeing up resources for other critical tasks.

Ethical data handling is not just about compliance or brand image; it’s about optimizing operations and resource allocation. A lean, ethically driven data strategy Meaning ● Data Strategy for SMBs: A roadmap to leverage data for informed decisions, growth, and competitive advantage. is often a more efficient data strategy.

Consider an SMB using customer relationship management (CRM) software. An unethical approach might involve importing vast amounts of publicly available data, even if irrelevant to the business, in the hope of finding some hidden insights. This clutters the CRM system, slows down performance, and increases data security vulnerabilities. An ethical approach, guided by data minimization, would focus on importing only data directly provided by customers and relevant to customer interactions.

This results in a cleaner, more efficient CRM system, faster data retrieval, and reduced storage costs. Moreover, proactively addressing data privacy concerns through transparency can minimize customer complaints and support tickets related to data handling, further enhancing operational efficiency. Ethical data practices, therefore, are not a drag on efficiency; they are an enabler of streamlined operations and resource optimization for SMBs.

Mitigating Regulatory and Reputational Risks

The regulatory landscape surrounding data privacy is becoming increasingly stringent, even for SMBs. While large corporations may have dedicated legal teams to navigate complex regulations like GDPR or CCPA, SMBs often lack these resources. However, the penalties for non-compliance can be proportionally more damaging to a smaller business. Ethical data practices, proactively implemented, can significantly mitigate regulatory risks.

By adhering to principles of transparency, data minimization, and customer control, SMBs can preemptively address many regulatory requirements, reducing the likelihood of fines and legal repercussions. Furthermore, in an era of heightened data privacy awareness, ethical data breaches are far less damaging to reputation than those stemming from negligence or unethical practices.

Imagine an SMB experiencing a data breach. If the breach is attributed to outdated security systems and a lack of basic data protection measures, the reputational damage can be severe and long-lasting. However, if the SMB has demonstrably invested in data security, adhered to ethical data principles, and acted transparently in response to the breach, the reputational impact may be significantly less. Customers are more forgiving of accidental breaches when they perceive a genuine commitment to ethical data stewardship.

Proactive ethical data practices, therefore, serve as a risk mitigation strategy, protecting SMBs from both regulatory penalties and severe reputational damage. This proactive approach is far more cost-effective than reactive crisis management after a data privacy failure.

Attracting and Retaining Talent

In today’s competitive talent market, particularly in technology-related fields, company values matter. Employees, especially younger generations, are increasingly seeking out employers who demonstrate ethical responsibility and social consciousness. SMBs that prioritize data ethics can leverage this to attract and retain top talent. A commitment to ethical data practices signals a broader commitment to ethical business operations, making the SMB a more attractive employer.

This is particularly relevant for SMBs in the tech sector or those reliant on data-driven roles, where attracting skilled professionals is crucial for growth and innovation. Ethical data practices can become a talent magnet, providing a competitive advantage Meaning ● SMB Competitive Advantage: Ecosystem-embedded, hyper-personalized value, sustained by strategic automation, ensuring resilience & impact. in the labor market.

Consider two tech startups competing for the same pool of software engineers. One startup emphasizes aggressive data monetization and rapid growth, with less focus on data ethics. The other startup explicitly promotes its commitment to ethical data practices, highlighting its transparency and customer-centric approach. The latter startup is likely to attract candidates who value ethical considerations and long-term sustainability over purely profit-driven motives.

These employees are often more engaged, loyal, and aligned with the company’s mission, contributing to a more positive and productive work environment. Ethical data practices, therefore, extend beyond customer relationships; they positively impact employee morale, talent acquisition, and overall organizational culture, indirectly but significantly contributing to SMB profitability Meaning ● SMB Profitability is the capacity to sustainably generate economic value for stakeholders while fostering resilience and ethical practices. and long-term success.

For SMBs, embracing strategic data stewardship Meaning ● Responsible data management for SMB growth and automation. is not merely virtuous; it’s a pragmatic pathway to sustainable competitive advantage and enduring profitability.

Data Ethics As A Strategic Imperative For Smb Ecosystem Resilience

The prevailing discourse often frames data ethics as a compliance burden or a corporate social responsibility initiative, overlooking its profound strategic implications for small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) operating within complex, interconnected ecosystems. For SMBs, data ethics transcends individual business practices; it becomes a critical determinant of ecosystem resilience, influencing not only individual profitability but also the collective health and sustainability of the broader business environment. In an era of algorithmic governance and data-driven economies, ethical data stewardship Meaning ● Ethical Data Stewardship for SMBs: Responsible data handling to build trust, ensure compliance, and drive sustainable growth in the digital age. is no longer a choice but a strategic imperative for SMBs seeking long-term viability and competitive robustness within their respective ecosystems.

Ecosystem Trust and Collaborative Advantage

SMBs rarely operate in isolation; they exist within intricate ecosystems comprising suppliers, partners, customers, and even competitors. Trust within these ecosystems is the social capital that facilitates collaboration, innovation, and collective value creation. Data ethics plays a pivotal role in fostering and maintaining this ecosystem trust. When SMBs within an ecosystem demonstrably adhere to ethical data practices, it cultivates a shared sense of responsibility and mutual respect, encouraging greater collaboration and information sharing.

This collaborative advantage can lead to synergistic growth opportunities that would be unattainable for individual SMBs acting in isolation. Ecosystem resilience Meaning ● SMB Ecosystem Resilience: Ability to withstand shocks, adapt, and thrive within a network of interconnected business elements. is fundamentally strengthened by a foundation of shared ethical data principles.

Consider a regional tourism ecosystem comprising hotels, restaurants, tour operators, and local artisans. If these SMBs collectively commit to ethical data practices ● transparently handling tourist data, respecting privacy preferences, and using data to enhance the overall tourist experience rather than exploit it ● they can cultivate a reputation for responsible tourism. This shared ethical commitment can attract a more discerning and loyal tourist base, benefiting all ecosystem participants. Furthermore, it can facilitate data sharing for collective marketing initiatives, optimized resource allocation, and enhanced service delivery.

This collaborative data ecosystem, built on ethical foundations, becomes more resilient to external shocks and competitive pressures. Ethical data practices, therefore, move beyond individual SMB advantage to become a catalyst for ecosystem-wide prosperity and resilience.

Algorithmic Accountability in Smb Networks

As SMBs increasingly integrate algorithmic tools into their operations ● from supply chain management to customer engagement platforms ● algorithmic accountability Meaning ● Taking responsibility for algorithm-driven outcomes in SMBs, ensuring fairness, transparency, and ethical practices. becomes a critical ethical and strategic concern. Within SMB ecosystems, the cumulative impact of algorithmic bias or opacity can have systemic consequences. If algorithms used by various SMBs within an ecosystem perpetuate discriminatory practices or lack transparency in decision-making, it can erode trust, create unfair competitive dynamics, and ultimately undermine ecosystem stability. Ethical data practices demand algorithmic accountability, ensuring that SMBs are not only responsible for their own algorithms but also collectively vigilant about the ethical implications of algorithms deployed across the ecosystem.

Imagine a supply chain ecosystem where multiple SMB suppliers rely on algorithmic platforms for inventory management and order fulfillment. If these algorithms are opaque or biased, they could inadvertently favor certain suppliers over others, create bottlenecks, or disrupt the entire supply chain. Furthermore, if algorithmic pricing models lack transparency, they could lead to price gouging or unfair pricing practices within the ecosystem. SMBs within this ecosystem need to collectively advocate for algorithmic accountability, demanding transparency from platform providers, auditing algorithms for bias, and establishing shared ethical guidelines for algorithmic deployment.

This collective approach to algorithmic accountability safeguards ecosystem fairness, promotes trust, and enhances overall supply chain resilience. Ethical data practices, therefore, extend to the algorithmic fabric of SMB ecosystems, ensuring responsible and equitable technological integration.

Data Sovereignty and Smb Ecosystem Autonomy

In an increasingly data-driven global economy, data sovereignty Meaning ● Data Sovereignty for SMBs means strategically controlling data within legal boundaries for trust, growth, and competitive advantage. ● the principle that data should be subject to the laws and governance structures of the jurisdiction where it is collected ● is becoming a crucial strategic consideration for SMB ecosystems. For SMBs, particularly those operating in localized or regional ecosystems, maintaining data sovereignty is essential for preserving ecosystem autonomy and protecting against external data exploitation. Ethical data practices align with data sovereignty principles by emphasizing local data control, transparent data governance, and respect for regional data regulations. SMB ecosystems Meaning ● Interconnected networks of SMBs and supporting actors, driving value, innovation, and resilience. that prioritize data sovereignty enhance their collective bargaining power, foster local innovation, and safeguard their long-term economic interests in the face of global data flows.

Ethical data practices are not merely a matter of individual SMB virtue; they are the building blocks of resilient, collaborative, and future-proof SMB ecosystems.

Consider a regional agricultural ecosystem comprising SMB farmers, processors, and distributors. If this ecosystem collectively adopts data sovereignty principles, they can establish a local data cooperative to manage agricultural data, ensuring that it benefits local stakeholders rather than being extracted by external corporations. This data cooperative can facilitate data sharing for optimized farming practices, supply chain efficiency, and market access, while maintaining local control over valuable agricultural data assets.

Furthermore, it can strengthen the ecosystem’s ability to negotiate with larger food corporations and protect local farmers’ interests in data-driven agricultural markets. Ethical data practices, aligned with data sovereignty, therefore empower SMB ecosystems to maintain autonomy, foster local innovation, and ensure equitable participation in the data economy.

Circular Data Economies and Smb Sustainability

The concept of a circular economy, focused on resource efficiency and waste reduction, extends to the realm of data. Circular data economies emphasize data reuse, data sharing, and responsible data disposal, minimizing data waste and maximizing the value derived from data assets throughout their lifecycle. For SMB ecosystems, embracing circular data principles can enhance sustainability, drive innovation, and create new revenue streams.

Ethical data practices are integral to circular data economies, ensuring that data reuse and sharing are conducted transparently, ethically, and with respect for privacy. SMB ecosystems that adopt circular data models can achieve greater resource efficiency, foster collaborative innovation, and contribute to a more sustainable data economy.

Imagine a manufacturing ecosystem comprising SMB component suppliers, assemblers, and recyclers. If this ecosystem adopts circular data principles, they can establish a shared data platform to track material flows, product lifecycles, and waste streams. This data sharing can facilitate material reuse, optimized recycling processes, and the development of closed-loop manufacturing systems. Furthermore, it can enable the creation of new data-driven services, such as product-as-a-service models or predictive maintenance offerings.

Ethical data practices are essential to ensure that data sharing within this circular economy is conducted transparently, with appropriate data security measures, and with respect for intellectual property rights. Circular data economies, underpinned by ethical data principles, therefore drive both economic and environmental sustainability for SMB ecosystems.

Future-Proofing Smb Ecosystems Through Anticipatory Ethics

In a rapidly evolving technological landscape, anticipatory ethics ● proactively considering the ethical implications of emerging technologies and data practices ● is crucial for SMB ecosystem Meaning ● Within the landscape of small and medium-sized businesses, an SMB ecosystem represents the interdependent network of resources, tools, technologies, and relationships crucial for growth, automation, and seamless implementation of strategies. resilience. For SMBs, often lacking the resources for extensive future-gazing, collective engagement in anticipatory ethics within their ecosystems is essential for navigating technological disruptions and mitigating future risks. Ethical data practices, grounded in principles of foresight and responsibility, enable SMB ecosystems to proactively adapt to technological change, anticipate ethical challenges, and collectively shape a more ethical and sustainable data-driven future. Anticipatory ethics becomes a shared strategic capability for future-proofing SMB ecosystems.

Consider a healthcare ecosystem comprising SMB clinics, pharmacies, and home healthcare providers. As AI-driven diagnostics and personalized medicine become more prevalent, this ecosystem needs to proactively consider the ethical implications of these technologies ● issues such as algorithmic bias in medical diagnoses, data privacy in personalized healthcare, and equitable access to AI-driven healthcare services. By engaging in collective anticipatory ethics, these SMBs can develop shared ethical guidelines for AI adoption, advocate for responsible AI regulation, and collaboratively shape a future of healthcare that is both technologically advanced and ethically sound. Anticipatory ethics, grounded in ethical data principles, therefore empowers SMB ecosystems to navigate technological uncertainty, mitigate future risks, and proactively shape a more ethical and sustainable future for their collective endeavors.

SMB ecosystems that strategically embrace data ethics are not merely adapting to the present; they are architecting their resilience and prosperity for a data-driven future.

References

• Zuboff, Shoshana. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism ● The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. PublicAffairs, 2019.
• O’Neil, Cathy. Weapons of Math Destruction ● How Big Data Increases Inequality and Threatens Democracy. Crown, 2016.
• Mittelstadt, Brent Daniel, et al. “The Ethics of Algorithms ● Current Landscape and Future Directions.” Big Data & Society, vol. 3, no. 2, 2016, pp. 1-21.
• Floridi, Luciano, and Mariarosaria Taddeo. “What is Data Ethics?” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A ● Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, vol. 374, no. 2083, 2016, pp. 1-8.
• Manyika, James, et al. “Data, privacy, and the individual ● and why it all matters.” McKinsey Quarterly, no. 3, 2014, pp. 1-17.